Banned Again: Toyota Prius TV Ad Gets Axed For Exaggerating CO2 benefits!

Believe it or not but the British Adverting Standards Authority (ASA) has banned a second Toyota hybrid-car related ad in a month! This time it’s for a Prius TV ad that misleadingly claims it emits less CO2 than an equivalent diesel engine family car. About a month ago, ASA pulled the plug off a Lexus RX 400h magazine advert for falsely implicating that it caused little or no harm to the environment and had low CO2 emissions in comparison with all cars.

The Prius TV commercial, created by Saatchi & Saatchi Japan, claimed “what if all cars were like the Prius, with its hybrid synergy drive technology, it emits up to one tonne less CO2 per year” On-screen text stated “1 tonne of CO2 less than an equivalent family vehicle with a diesel engine. Average calculated on 20,000km a year. Toyota Prius: CO2 emissions: 104g/km”.

The problem was that, according to ASA’s investigations, the chart used by Toyota to make the calculations held data on petrol and diesel cars as opposed to merely diesel. Moreover, while the average annual distance driven by private cars in the US was 20,000km, the average for the UK was 13,440km. -Click “Read More…” for ASA’s press release

Ad: A TV ad, for the Toyota Prius, claimed “what if all cars were like the Prius, with its hybrid synergy drive technology, it emits up to one tonne less CO2 per year” On-screen text stated “1 tonne of CO2 less than an equivalent family vehicle with a diesel engine. Average calculated on 20,000km a year. Toyota Prius: CO2 emissions: 104g/km”.

Issue: The complainant challenged whether the claim “it emits up to one tonne less CO2 per year” misleadingly exaggerated the environmental benefits of the car.

Response: Toyota sent a chart that took an average of the emissions of new cars registered in 2005 and compared that with the emissions of the Prius. The chart showed that, on average, new cars registered in 2005 emitted 172g of CO2 / km, while the Prius emitted 104g / km. They said they had taken the difference of 68g/km and multiplied it by 20,000km, which they considered a reasonable average annual distance travelled by a car. That gave an emissions saving of 1.36 tonnes. The chart also gave emissions figures for individual cars with engines of between 1.2 and 2.2 litres. They said they had chosen 1.8 litres as a threshold of comparison because although the Prius had a 1.5 litre engine, they believed its output was comparable to a 2.0 litre engine. They sent a document that compared the output of the current Prius with the first generation Prius hybrid and the Toyota Allion, which had a 2.0 litre engine. They argued the chart showed that the Toyota Prius emitted one tonne less of CO2 than a range of cars with engines either side of their threshold of comparison and pointed out they had qualified the claim by stating “up to” 1 tonne less to make clear that the emissions saved would not always be as much as 1 tonne.

The Broadcast Advertising Clearance Centre (BACC) said they had checked Toyota’s evidence with an independent consultant, who had advised it was suitable to show that the Toyota Prius emitted significantly less CO2 than other cars.

Assessment: Upheld

The ASA noted on-screen text stated that the claim compared the Prius with “an equivalent family vehicle with a diesel engine” and that it made clear calculations were based on an annual driving distance of 20,000km a year. However, we noted that the chart sent by Toyota held data on petrol and diesel cars and that, while the average annual distance driven by private cars in the US was 20,000km, the average for the UK was 13,440km.

We noted that the chart drew on UK government data and compared the Prius against a range of cars from different manufacturers, but the document that measured the output of the car was produced inhouse and only compared the Prius against the previous model and another Toyota car.

We did not consider that document suitable to establish that the output of the Prius was comparable to all 2.0 litre cars registered in 2005. We noted that none of the cars with 1.5 litre engines featured in the chart emitted 1 tonne more CO2 than the Prius and that less than half of those new cars that had engines of less than 1.8 litres emitted 1 tonne more CO2 than the Prius.

We noted that Toyota had qualified the claim by stating “up to one ton less CO2 per year” and that the Prius emitted significantly less CO2 than some other cars with greater engine capacity, but we did not consider their evidence demonstrated that it emitted 1 tonne less than equivalent vehicles with diesel engines or that it took into account the average annual distance driven by private cars in the UK.

The ad breached CAP (Broadcast) TV Advertising Standards Code rules 5.1 (Misleading advertising), 5.2.1 (Evidence), 5.2.2 (Implications), 5.2.6 (Environmental claims) and 5.4.6 (Comparative advertising).

Action: The ad should not be broadcast again in the same form.

Technorati: , Toyota+Prius, Lexus, Carscoop, blogs, automotive, vehicles

Porsche 911 GT3 RS Goes Too Fast, Ends Up On Patch Of Grass

Just a reminder: Porsche drivers also have to use the brake pedal just like anyone else.

How Do You Like The New BMW M5 On Satin Black Wheels?

The rims feature a five-double spoke design and are available in 35 different colors.

2019 Vanderhall Carmel Boasts 200 HP, Adds Doors And Removable Top

The latest iteration of the autocycle features a 1.5-liter GM-sourced four-cylinder and a number of (previously unavailable) amenities .

Teslaquila Could Pack Some Serious Voltage – If Musk’s Not Pulling Our Chain

Either Musk is doubling down on an April Fool’s joke, or Tesla is getting serious about bringing its own tequila to market.

2019 Chevrolet Blazer Starts From $30k, Tops Out At Almost $49,000

The entry level version is quite affordable, but moving up in the range requires spending significantly more.

2019 Porsche Panamera GTS Debuts With 453 HP

The new Panamera GTS has 19 hp and 73 lb-ft of torque more than its predecessor.

Hennessey’s 1200 HP Jeep Grand Cherokee Trackhawk Claims To Be The Fastest Accelerating SUV In The World

The Grand Cherokee rockets from 0-60 mph in 2.3 second and tops out at 200+ mph.

Tesla Models Hit Cut Off For Full $7,500 Government Rebate

Starting in January, Tesla vehicles will have only have a federal tax credit of $3,750.

Porsche Board Member Confirms Electric Crossover Arriving By 2022

The upcoming electric crossover will be “big,” but it remains unclear if it will be an all-new model or a version of the Cayenne.

2020 BMW Alpina B7 Facelift Spotted With Texas-Sized Grille And Sportier Front Bumper

The 2020 Alpina B7 will feature a more aggressive design than the standard model.