Can The Kia Stinger Take On The All-Aussie Holden Commodore?

The Kia Stinger has sent hearts racing around the world from the moment it was revealed and in Australia, is set to dramatically shake up the industry.

As both the locally-produced Ford Falcon and Holden Commodore are now dead and many manufacturers are turning towards crossovers and SUVs, the Kia Stinger needs to work its way into the hearts and minds of horsepower-loving Australians. Can it do the job?

To find out, Car Advice pitted the twin-turbo V6 variant of the Stinger against the Holden Commodore SS-V Redline, one of the final variants of the all-Aussie Commodore before sales of the re-badged Opel Insignia commence.

Before seeing which of the two is more practical and better to drive on the street, Car Advice conducted a number of performance tests between the two and the results are very, very close.

Which would you pick?

VIDEO

  • Craig

    And no doubt – the person testing these cars is FAR more familiar with the Holden than the KIA.

    • Bash

      Agreed

    • Mike Stevens

      Well, yeah, we’ve had years to get to know the commodore!

  • john1168

    I’ve seen faster times in the Holden/Chevy SS but this test appears to have been done with both cars on the same track, on the same day, under the same conditions, with the same configuration of car (both rear wheel drive as Aussie’s aren’t getting AWD) and as Craig stated, tested by people who have quite a bit of experience with Holdens. I’m stunned that the Stinger did 12.79 in the quarter mile! That’s pretty quick! I was expecting low 13’s but not that!

  • THEY BOTH HAVE THOSE UGLY [ BRACKETS ] IN THE BUMPERS. TIME TO RETIRE THAT OVERUSED FAD.

    • no25

      time to retire commenting in all caps – quite the overuse fad for you, hypocrite.

      • Bash

        I dont think he can read or understand what you are saying.

        • exeptor

          Nice one :).

        • no25

          I probably should have wrote it in all caps…

          • Bash

            Hilarious !! Hahaha

    • Enter Ranting

      The fake grilles in the bumper are on every car sold today, and make no sense on any of them.

  • Shobin Drogan

    I like aussie cars but lets be honest the ageing holden is seriously outclassed here. Put the kia up against some real competitors.

    • O123

      Like what?

      • Knotmyrealname

        Well the Insignia is the replacement; frankly I was astounded they compared that dinosaur to the Kia.

        • Cupboi

          But the Insignia is FWD, and it doesn’t even pretend to have the sporting credentials the current Commodore has. It would be kinda pointless to compare it against the Kia.

          • Knotmyrealname

            The Holden Insignia V6 will be all-wheel drive.

          • Cupboi

            A FWD-based all-wheel drive sedan with a heavy engine at the front built by a company that is synonimous with understeer? Boy, if this isn’t the perfect recipe for fun, i don’t what is O.o

          • Knotmyrealname

            I don’t get your replies as they don’t relate to your previous ones. You seem incapable of maintaining a normal conversation flow.

          • Cupboi

            Just saying how this is nonsense. Wouldn’t the Insignia compete with the Optima? Again, you’re the one not making much sense here.

      • Shobin Drogan

        A5 sportback and 4 series gran coupe are its main competitors.

    • JIMI JAMES

      Just because you can’t drive for sht,wheres the proper proof?others nailed 12.7 flat on a ss,the tunability of the commodore is far more affording than just the odd spewcial tweaked prototype for the fools to comprehend,you don’t build world leading 4 door saloon cars just for some demented moron to assume ot a joke!
      i like to see how well the faddy kia can cope towing real mans commodity like boat,caravan,trailers and on over the outback outclassed?
      get ye hand off it!

      • Shobin Drogan

        Triggered much? World leading 4 door sedan? Lol Is that why Holden is dead and absolutely nobody bought the Chevy ss? The commodores interior is worse than a 2017 fiesta. Also whothef in this segment tows trailers with these cars? Thats like 0.1% of the market share. Get out of your country for once and you’ll see there’s more to cars than towin’ and quarter mile times and effin your sister in the back seat.

  • JIMI JAMES

    The testers cannot test without the proper wheel alignment,tyre pressures,optional brake compounds and precise timing of gear changes,kia obviously had theirs tweaked,come in time you’ll see exactly what i mean,irrespective the commodore is race track dna and much stronger + robust car overall to say the very least!never mind the paid whims!

  • SteersUright

    Why didn’t they us a RWD Stinger which would be much better matched?

    • It is. The Stinger is only available in rear-wheel drive in Australia.

      • SteersUright

        Wait what??? He specifically says, “this Stinger gets off the line better with its all wheel drive”, didn’t he?

        • I don’t think I ever said that! Hah, play it again.

  • SteersUright

    The Stinger already looks old to me, not a great design. I saw one in a showroom the other night. Its nice, but looks like its already been out for a few years and in need of a refresh already.

Chelsea’s 2017 Jeep Night Eagle Has A Thing Or Two To Show The New Wrangler

This extensively modified 2017 Wrangler Unlimited is listed for nearly $80k – used
.

FIA Announces Budgets For 2020 Hypercar-Based Prototype Endurance Class

Automakers like McLaren, Aston Martin and Toyota have expressed interest to compete in the new Le Mans category.

Topsy-Turvy Cement Truck Falls Into A Bunch Of Cars

The driver of this cement tanker reportedly lost control during what looked like a simple right-hand turn.

Ferrari GTC4Lusso Turned Into A Modern-Day 412 By Ares Design

This coachbuilt Ferrari looks quite impressive, but costs more than twice the price of a new GTC4Lusso.

New BMW X5 xDrive50i Looks Dashing In Phytonic Blue Metallic

This is an xDrive50i model, which means that power comes from a twin-turbo 4.4-liter V8.

Certain 2017-2018MY Audi R8s Recalled Stateside Over Fire Concerns

Nearly 2,000 units of the second-gen R8 Coupe and Spyder have been included in this safety campaign.

Manhart Tunes Porsche 911 Turbo To 670 HP, Performance Almost Matches The GT2 RS

This tuned 911 Turbo has 680 PS and 870 Nm of torque, and sprints to 100 km/h in 2.9 seconds.

Porsche Taycan To Be Priced Between The Cayenne And Panamera

The Taycan could cost anywhere between $65,700 and $85,000..

Google Maps Will Now Find You The Nearest EV Charging Station

Both Tesla as well as Chargepoint’s global network of EV chargers has been added to the iOS and Android versions of Google Maps.

2019 Yenko Camaro Lineup Revealed With Up To 1000 HP

Customers can also order a Yenko/SC Stage 1 Camaro with 835 hp.