Hybrids Dominate Consumer Reports 10 Top Picks For 2024

Toyota took four wins in the study, which rates cars based on road tests, predicted reliability, safety and customer satisfaction

Add CarScoops on Google:
Google Discover

Sales of electrified vehicles are growing in the U.S., and so is their credibility. Consumer Reports has just revealed its 10 Top Picks for 2024 and the list is dominated by cars featuring, or available with, some kind of electric drive system.

CR's annual list divides vehicles into market segments then scores them based on their road test performance, predicted reliability, safety and reported levels of customer satisfaction. Subaru, one of only two brands in the list whose entries didn't include a hybrid or EV option, claimed two different awards, the Crosstrek being ranked best subcompact SUV and the Forester, best compact SUV.

Related: Hybrid Sales In The US Expected To Triple By 2028

And Toyota performed twice as well, taking home four gongs. The automaker's Prius and Prius Prime were named best hybrid/PHEV, the Camry Hybrid came away with the best midsize car award, the Highland Hybrid was best midsized SUV and CR picked the RAV4 Prime as its favorite PHEV SUV.

Top Model Picks
Category Vehicle
Subcompact SUV Subaru Crosstrek
Hybrid/PHEV car Toyota Prius/Prius Prime
Compact SUV Subaru Forester
Small car Mazda 3
Midsized car Toyota Camry Hybrid
Small pickup Ford Maverick/Maverick Hybrid
Electric vehicle Tesla Model Y
Midsized SUV Toyota Highlander Hybrid
Luxury SUV BMW X5/X5 PHEV
Plug-in hybrid SUV Toyota RAV4 Prime

The sole EV on the list is the Tesla Model Y, which the study declared best electric vehicle, praising its packaging, long driving range and the reliability of its Supercharger charging network, while also noting that in most cases drivers spend their energy dollars more efficiently when they choose a full EV. But CR warned that owners in states with higher electricity costs might be better off with a hybrid.

Consumer Reports' team also published its annual brand report card for 2024, again using the same criteria of road test impressions, safety, reliability and customer satisfaction. BMW came out tops, with Subaru, Porsche, Honda and Lexus occupying the next four spots on the positive end of the league table.

The spaces at the other end were filled by the same old brands we always seem to see getting a kicking in these kinds of studies. Jeep came dead last, taking 34th spot and beating out Land Rover and Jaguar, but Mercedes (29th) and Rivian (30th) won't be happy with their performances.

Consumer Reports 2024 Brand Report Card
Position Brand Score
1 BMW 82
2 Subaru 80
3 Porsche 80
4 Honda 78
5 Lexus 78
6 Mini 78
7 Kia 77
8 Mazda 77
9 Toyota 77
10 Hyundai 76
11 Acura 73
12 Audi 72
13 Buick 69
14 Cadillac 68
15 Genesis 68
16 Infiniti 67
17 Ford 65
18 Tesla 65
19 Nissan 64
20 Mitsubishi 64
21 Lincoln 63
22 Chevrolet 62
23 Volvo 62
24 Chrysler 62
25 Dodge 61
26 Volkswagen 60
27 Maserati 56
28 Alfa Romeo 56
29 Mercedes-Benz 55
30 Rivian 55
31 GMC 53
32 Jaguar 52
33 Land Rover 50
34 Jeep 46

Recommended