BMW Thought Hyundai's Fake Shifts Were A Gimmick — Then Its Engineers Tried Them

Paddle shifters on an EV?

Add CarScoops on Google:
Google Discover

If imitation is, indeed, the sincerest form of flattery, Hyundai should be pretty proud of itself right now. When it launched the Ioniq 5 N in 2023, this performance-minded EV didn't appear to be any sort of groundbreaking car, but today, we're all starting to realize just how innovative the South Korean automaker's approach was. One such example is the car's "N e-Shift" system, which simulates the feeling of an eight-speed dual-clutch transmission (DCT). How innovative was this idea? Enough for BMW not only to take notice, but also to admit that Hyundai spurred it on to add something similar to the new i3.

In a new interview with CarSale.com.au, BMW Dynamics Engineer Christian Heiss lays out what happened. During development of the new i3, Hyundai launched the Ioniq 5 N. Speaking specifically about the gear shift idea, he says, "We at BMW thought: well, that's a funny gimmick. We're in an electric world; why copy things out of the combustion engine?" Then, they drove the thing. That's why when the BMW i3 goes on sale next year, performance versions will get simulated gear shifts, called "Stages."

The interview

Adding a little theater could be the difference between a success and another somewhat soulless flop, but BMW being its own proud company, it isn't just going to copy Hyundai, though. "We've ended up with something close to a gearbox simulation, but we don't call it a gearbox simulation. It's thought [out] a bit differently, but everyone hoping for a gear shift simulation will be happy with this -– hopefully even more than happy," Heiss said.

"From the driving dynamics side, we pointed out that there are some advantages to having this kind of paddle shift, in terms of drivability and feedback from the car. It's an improvement on certain kinds of drives, and especially on track," Heiss added. The connection between drivability and feedback isn't hard to understand, either. Engagement is the one big piece of the puzzle seemingly missing from performance EVs — even at the top of the segment, EVs seem to struggle against their combustion counterparts.

Some kind of simulated gear shifts could definitely help to narrow that gap, but BMW's "Stages" feature won't be available across the lineup. Heiss claims it will only be available on the M Performance grades, which, for now, is only i3 M60. It would seem that BMW is intentionally putting this feature behind a paywall of sorts, but Heiss says that it comes down to physical paddle shifters, which the performance models get and the others don't. That's a bit of a downer, but the reality is that it's great to see automakers trying to add engagement wherever they can.

Recommended