2018 BMW X3 Takes On Audi Q5 And Volvo XC60 In Premium Compact SUV Squabble

Trying to decide between a BMW X3, a Volvo XC60 and an Audi Q5 can be really difficult once you start looking at what each model brings to the table. They’re all remarkably good.

Of course, while the destination might be the same, the road taken does differ, meaning that these three SUVs have three very different styles, both inside and out. So then let’s go ahead and see what Carwow editor Mat Watson had to say about them, before choosing a winner at the end.

The only exterior design he found rather uninspiring was the Audi’s, although the X3’s gigantic kidney grille didn’t sit well with our reviewer either – the term “flared nostrils” was used. The BMW did look the sportiest, according to Watson, while the Volvo’s elegant styling was also very much appreciated, especially in Inscription trim.

Feel free to be picky

Inside, while all three feature excellent build quality and great tech, it’s the Volvo that offers just a bit more room for passengers, with a surprisingly comfortable center seat for a third passenger in the rear. The BMW X3 sits at the other end of that spectrum, with the least amount of space out back – although its boot was the most practical, while the Audi Q5’s the most spacious, without the rear seats folded.

On the road, it’s the X3 that goes around corners with more composure than its rivals, without sacrificing comfort. In fact, Watson says you get the best of both worlds with this car, which is something he took into account while delivering his verdict.

Which one of these three would you go for?

  • Bash

    I love the X3 more than the other two. Although the Volvo has the best interior among the three.

  • izzey04

    Volvo really not in my mind when looking for a new car..the brand just doesn’t excite me..to me at least

    • Belthronding

      most probably it is only you,at least.

      • Alexander

        nope, to me either. Not to mention that Volvo just doesn’t have an engine

  • Belthronding

    game over germans.

  • Autoexperte
    • Tostik

      Nice car. Worthy competitor. I’ll still take the XC60.

  • Jesse A. C. Majors

    Sorry but the bmw nostrils are just hideous.
    I own a 2011 Q5 and it looks sportier than the 2018. They’ve gone too conservative.
    The Volvo just looks rushed toward the back window. The front and inside are beautiful

  • shamrock


2019 LA Auto Show Preview: A-To-Z Guide To All The Debuts (Updated)

The most comprehensive list of all the world and North American premieres at the 2019 LA Auto Show.

2020 Aston Martin DBX Comes Off As Surprisingly Practical During In-Depth Static Review

The 2020 Aston Martin DBX also sounds off with its twin-turbo 4.0-liter V8 during this video.

Infiniti Excites Us (Not) In Los Angeles With “Edition 30” Models

Infiniti’s Q50, Q60, QX50, QX60 and QX80 Edition 30 are on display at the 2019 LA Auto Show.

2020 Dodge Challenger 50th Anniversary Edition Celebrates Birthday With Gold Touches And Badges Galore

The Dodge Challenger turns 50 and wants to celebrate with new heritage paint options and a unique spec.

2020 Buick Envision Facelift And New Enclave SUVs Go Official In China

2020 Buick Envision could make it to the U.S. but the Enclave is for China only.

New Audi RS Q8 Is A Ballistic SUV With 591 HP And Mild-Hybrid Tech

The RS Q8 is the flagship of Audi’s SUV family and will launch in the first quarter of 2020.

Bugatti Chief Says Company Will Resist Electrification

Bugatti could continue making ICE-powered cars for at least one more decade.

Bill Ford Didn’t Think The Mach-E Should Get The ‘Mustang’ Moniker – But Then He Drove It

Ford executive chairman Bill Ford had to give the Mach-E team his OK with regards to the car’s full name.

Chrysler Pays Homage To Australia’s 1969 Valiant Pacer With 300 SRT Special Edition

The unique Chrysler 300 SRT pays tribute to Australia’s beloved 1969 Valiant Pacer.

Faraday Future FF 91’s Interior Revealed As A Tech And Luxury Cornucopia

The big question is obviously whether Faraday Future will get to finally launch the FF 91.