The Brands With The Most 5-Star Safety Ratings Over The Last 10 Years

Jeep owners filed over 1,487 complaints per car, outpacing every other brand by an astronomical margin

Add CarScoops on Google:
Google Discover
  • Several automakers haven't launched a single new model in ten years without 5-star ratings.
  • Genesis, Polestar, Buick, and Acura also performed strongly with consistently high safety scores.
  • Volvo and Genesis reported the fewest customer complaints among all major automotive brands.

A new study reveals which car brands have dominated the safety ratings game in the U.S. over the last decade, shedding light on which automakers prioritize keeping their vehicles as safe as possible—or at least safe enough to pass standardized tests.

While the results seem reassuring, it's worth asking: how much weight should we actually give these 5-star ratings when it comes to real-world performance? After all, these aren't crash reports from actual accidents but rather controlled assessments under idealized conditions.

Read: Tall SUVs And Pickups 2-3 Times Deadlier For Pedestrians In Crashes, IIHS Study Finds

The study, put together by Confused, analyzed data from the New Car Assessment Program (NCAP), which rates a vehicle's safety based on crash test performance, rollover resistance, and the effectiveness of advanced driver assistance systems (ADAS).

It identifies Volvo, Subaru, Tesla, Genesis, and Polestar as the (percentage) champions of safety tests. Every single new model released by these brands in the past decade has received a 5-star rating. That's undeniably impressive on paper, but the reality is more complicated.

For starters, these tests are designed around specific crash scenarios, meaning a perfect score doesn't necessarily guarantee the same level of protection in a chaotic highway pile-up or a poorly lit rural road. Additionally, the number of models tested matters—there's a significant difference between evaluating three cars and testing over 100 from a single brand.

Volvo and Subaru: Leaders in the Lab

Leading the pack is Volvo, with 76 models achieving 5-star NCAP ratings in the past decade. Subaru comes in close behind with 72, followed by Tesla with 45. Positioned alongside these brands are Genesis and Polestar. Both of these companies are newer entrants to the market and, therefore, haven't released as many cars. Nevertheless, each of them to be launched has received top safety marks.

Other top performers in the study (especially if you take into account the number of cars versus Polestar and Genesis), include Buick, with 98.31% of its cars getting 5-star ratings, followed by Acura with 98.18%, Honda with 94.59%, Mazda at 92.73%, and BMW at 91.30%. On the other hand, four brands, namely Mini, Fiat, Smart and Suzuki, failed to deliver a single 5-star-rated vehicle during the same period.

Brands With The Most 5-Star Rated Cars
MAKE Cars Tested w/ 5 Stars Percent 5-Star Safety Scores
VOLVO 76 76 100.00%
SUBARU 72 72 100.00%
TESLA 45 45 100.00%
GENESIS 15 15 100.00%
POLESTAR 3 3 100.00%
BUICK 59 58 98.31%
ACURA 55 54 98.18%
HONDA 111 105 94.59%
MAZDA 55 51 92.73%
BMW 92 84 91.30%
AUDI 113 102 90.27%
VW 87 76 87.36%
LINCOLN 58 50 86.21%
LEXUS 105 90 85.71%
INFINITI 32 27 84.38%
MERCEDES 34 28 82.35%
TOYOTA 194 148 76.29%
HYUNDAI 101 72 71.29%
CADILLAC 61 42 68.85%
KIA 96 66 68.75%
CHRYSLER 34 22 64.71%
CHEVROLET 169 109 64.50%
FORD 256 152 59.38%
DODGE 51 26 50.98%
NISSAN 121 61 50.41%
MITSUBISHI 45 16 35.56%
GMC 83 29 34.94%
JEEP 41 6 14.63%
RAM 33 4 12.12%
MINI 14 0 0.00%
FIAT 4 0 0.00%
SMART 4 0 0.00%
SUZUKI 1 0 0.00%

The same study provides us with some other interesting industry trends. For example, cars built in 2024 have the highest proportion of 5-star safety ratings on record. This comes after a slight dip in average safety ratings in 2022, thought to have been triggered by carmakers using lower-quality parts and microchips in the midst of industry-wide shortages.

What About Customer Complaints?

However, safety ratings only tell part of the story. Customer complaints filed with the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) offer a more grounded perspective on how these vehicles perform outside the lab.

Volvo and Genesis excel here too, with the fewest complaints per car with an average of 47.20 complaints made to the NHTSA per car launched. Other top performers included Polestar, Lexus, Audi, Mitsubishi, Smart, Lincoln, Cadillac, and Acura.

Fewest Complaints Per Car Most Complaints Per Car
Volvo 47 Jeep 1,488
Genesis 47 Dodge 925
Polestar 53.67 Chrysler 893.82
Lexus 68.24 Ram 702.82
Audi 70.35 Chevrolet 526.41

At the other end of the spectrum, Jeep owners filed an astronomical 1,487.83 complaints per car, making it the worst brand in this metric by a significant margin. Dodge, Chrysler, and Ram also fared poorly, with hundreds of complaints per car.

Customer complaint data adds nuance to the conversation about safety. While a high safety rating is important, a car with persistent technical issues, build quality problems, or ineffective ADAS systems can still create dangerous situations on the road. Tesla, for instance, boasts a perfect 5-star NCAP record but racks up 391.11 complaints per car.

Brands With The Fewest NHTSA Complaints
MAKE Total Cars Included Since 2024 Count of Complaints 2015-2019 Count 2020-2024 Total Complaints Complaints per Car Tested
VOLVO 76 1717 1870 3587 47.20
GENESIS 15 63 645 708 47.20
POLESTAR 3 0 161 161 53.67
LEXUS 105 4871 2294 7165 68.24
AUDI 113 3791 4159 7950 70.35
MITSUBISHI 45 2282 1430 3712 82.49
SMART 4 248 95 343 85.75
LINCOLN 58 3556 2699 6255 107.84
CADILLAC 61 4861 3488 8349 136.87
ACURA 55 3940 4098 8038 146.15
INFINITI 32 2775 1919 4694 146.69
BUICK 59 5451 3240 8691 147.31
MINI 14 1526 895 2421 172.93
MAZDA 55 7177 4345 11522 209.49
BMW 92 12434 7992 20426 222.02
VW 87 12395 10096 22491 258.52
MERCEDES 34 3190 6015 9205 270.74
TOYOTA 194 35242 21385 56627 291.89
GMC 83 13283 10982 24265 292.35
SUBARU 72 8651 13949 22600 313.89
KIA 96 12910 22917 35827 373.20
NISSAN 121 27461 17989 45450 375.62
TESLA 45 1562 16038 17600 391.11
FIAT 4 1066 508 1574 393.50
HYUNDAI 101 19488 25999 45487 450.37
HONDA 111 27277 30399 57676 519.60
CHEVROLET 169 53287 35677 88964 526.41
FORD 256 79361 69775 149136 582.56
RAM 33 8010 15183 23193 702.82
CHRYSLER 34 21960 8430 30390 893.82
DODGE 51 35113 12073 47186 925.22
SUZUKI 1 903 164 1067 1067.00
JEEP 41 35593 25408 61001 1487.83

Recommended