Face Off: New Audi RS3 vs. Mercedes A45 AMG [w/Poll]

The hottest hatch ever designed by Audi will make its debut at the Geneva Motor Show in March 2015, and by the looks of it, Mercedes-Benz should be worried.

We love our hot hatches. There’s just something about a small car with a big attitude that makes you buy into that whole underdog thing. Just like with movies when the nerd gets the cheerleader, we feel a certain level of gratification to see a smaller, cheaper car take on a bona fide sports car or simply a much more expensive car and show it the business end of its tail pipes.

It’s hard to find a generation of car enthusiasts nowadays that wouldn’t understand the appeal of owning a hot hatch. It’s as true now as it was 30 years ago or will be 30 years from now (according to our crystal ball and historical precedents). 
But since this is 2014, which is almost over anyway, the times are indeed changing as far as how fast you can really go with one of these boy-racer type of vehicles.

The Mercedes-Benz A 45 AMG broke the internet way before Kim Kardashian, for those of us who knew what it meant reaching 62 mph in just 4.6 seconds inside a small family hatchback. For a while there, it looked like nothing was going to challenge that sort of brute force. Its 360PS (355hp) 2.0 liter turbocharged engine is also capable of producing 450Nm of torque (331 lb-ft) from 2250rpm and onwards. While its performance oriented 4Matic four-wheel drive system makes sure it puts all that power down properly. Plain and simple, it’s a beast.

However, seen as though there is a Yin to every Yang, here comes Audi and their new generation RS3 hot hatchback. And when I say Yin and Yang, I’m referring to the different philosophies embodied by Mercedes-Benz and Audi when making cars, because as far as the A 45 AMG and the RS3 are concerned, they are quite similar.

The Audi RS3 packs a 5 cylinder, 2.5 litre TFSI engine, good for 367PS (362hp) that go along with its 465 Nm (342 lb-ft) of torque. Together with its excellent Quattro four wheel drive system, the RS3 will go from 0 to 62 mph in just 4.3 seconds. Yes you read that correctly. To put that into perspective, the fighting bull formerly known as the Lamborghini Gallardo (Standard – 5.0 liter V10) would reach 62 mph in the same interval. Amazing, right?

What makes the new RS 3 almost half a second quicker than the A 45 AMG, considering the fact that the Merc is 40kg lighter, is surprisingly not the extra bump in power. It’s close to insignificant.

What truly makes a difference off the line when you’re already at a weight disadvantage, is the extra torque, the four wheel drive system and definitely the transmission. Audi’s new generation seven speed S tronic dual-clutch transmission has proved to be phenomenally fast and it’s only natural for it to aid the RS3 when gunning it at full throttle.

Is it safe to assume that in this particular case, Quattro beats 4Motion? We’re still a long way from seeing any comparison tests between the two of them, but calling it in favor of Audi’s famous all-wheel drive system isn’t by any means a stretch. They have a lot more experience with very powerful all-wheel drive cars, unlike Mercedes-Benz and their traditional rear-wheel drive AMG models.

By Sergiu Tudose

Poll: Which one would you take home?

Photo Gallery

  • Kash

    both forbidden fruit for me in the US (well unless i wanna buy a GLA 45, remove the plastic around the bottom and drop the suspension) but the A45 has my vote.

    Edit: i do like the Audi’s interior more than the Benz’s

  • bob

    mercedes 1-uped audi by tuning the engine to 365 hp and gets to 60 in 4.1 seconds euro spec for 2015 modles

  • donald seymour

    Its all based on looks for me. One look likes a chick’s car and other looks like a man’s car. I will go with the Audi.

  • Craig

    It’s interesting how they both use after-market looking navigation systems. The MB especially looks like something a customer bought later and attached to the top of the dashboard.

  • KF

    The front on the Audi looks so dull

  • CFK

    M2 is coming.

    • Kash

      okay, well the 2 series is now only coupes and convertibles. Now if BMW made a 1-Series M hatch back, then that’s the one you’d compare against these two, not the 2 series.

  • dinn

    A45.

  • saminsomniac

    The A45 is the ultimate hatch, ever. Merc has never made a hot hatch before this. And they just nailed it in the first attempt. The Merc by a LARGE MARGIN.

  • John34

    why ‘nearly half a second’ when on paper it is 0.3 sec and the A45 has been clocked officially at 4.4 sec that makes it 1/10 slower and probably $25000 cheaper when the RS3 lands in Australia

Ferrari’s P80/C, SP3JC And Monza SP2 Coming To Goodwood

Ferrari will also bring along seven race cars driven by F1 legend Michael Schumacher.

BMW M4 GT4 Slams Into Pit Wall After Being Blinded By Flying Hood

Even the BMW driver’s pit crew found the incident to be quite funny, .

This South African Has Built A Sauber-Mercedes C9 Replica

Powering this Sauber-Mercedes C9 replica is a twin-turbocharged 3.2-liter V6.

2019 Mercedes-Benz G550 Is A Very Good Excuse Not To Buy The AMG G63

In short, if you can afford the new G-Wagen, buy it, you won’t regret it.

FCA’s Uconnect Market Lets You Make Purchases And Reservations From Your Car’s Touchscreen

The automaker will deploy its Uconnect Market platform in the second half of this year.

2020 VW Golf Mk8: Why Bother With Camo When It’s That Evolutionary?

VW was spotted testing the new Golf Mk8 with no camo – again.

2019 Ford Focus ST Offers Faster In-Gear Acceleration Than Previous AWD Focus RS

The new fast Ford Focus ST also hits 0-62mph (100km/h) in just 5.7 seconds.

Watch A Tesla Model 3 Drive Through The Boring Company’s LA Tunnel

The Boring Company’s LA test tunnel is only wide enough for one vehicle.

Lewis Hamilton And Mercedes Look Unstoppable This Year

Mercedes claimed its eighth straight win of 2019 in France, which was concurrently Hamilton’s fourth straight.

Citroen Won’t Give The C4 Cactus Another Chance

The name might return but the quirky crossover is not coming back, says Citroen’s product chief.