Porsche Cayman GTS Vs. Boxster GTS: Which One Should You Get?

If you’d like an entry-level Porsche but nothing as basic as, say, an entry level, 2.0-liter 718 Cayman or Boxster, you can opt for their GTS versions instead that have an extra 65 hp squeezed from their 2.5-liter turbocharged four-cylinder, or 15 more than the similarly sized S.

Altogether, you get 365 PS (360 HP) at your disposal, and if you can afford the PDK versions, you’ll be hitting 100 km/h (62 mph) in as little as 4.1 seconds, as opposed to the 4.6 seconds if you opt for the manual instead.

Yet, the reviewers from The Straight Pipes seem to prefer having to operate the clutch themselves, saying that their ideal Cayman/Boxster GTS configuration involves the 6-speed manual transmission, where one of them would even rather have a Cayman GTS over a base-spec 911 Carrera – something we figure is definitely worth debating.

It’s worth noting that the PDK versions have slightly more torque and will launch you off the line harder than the ones with the manual transmission. So if straight line speed is all that matters to you, opting for the PDK over the 6-speed manual is kind of a no-brainer.

Of course, these two are about way more than raw power, and perfectly capable of reminding you why you love driving so much, a trait held by most rear-wheel drive Porsche models.

In the U.S., you can purchase a 718 Cayman GTS from $80,700, whereas the Boxster GTS will set you back a bit more, at $82,800. Meanwhile, the cheapest 911 you can buy, the base-spec Carrera, costs upwards of $91,100.


  • pcurve

    Do you guys remember when Porsche charged MORE for Cayman than Boxster?

  • SteersUright

    I had a PDK Cayman S and manual 911. Both cars awesome. Both transmissions were incredible. Very tough choice. The weighted manual in the 911 was one of the best I’ve every used but PDK was so fast and exciting, combined with the amazing sounding flat-6, you felt like a race-car driver. I still struggle to know which I enjoyed more.
    Oh yeah, electrical gremlins and some quality issues with both, typical of modern German high performance cars.

  • Bash

    Cayman is the one for me.

    • Trackhacker


  • Joe Mosely

    The 911 has the flat 6. The 718 has the flat 4 that sounds like a Subaru. The visceral experience is impacted.

    • ksegg

      +1 F6 all day long.

  • ksegg

    Neither. Was never sold into that whole “premium” 2 seater vert thing.

    If all you wanted was a fun 2 seater roadster, then just get a new ND2 Miata for $30K new and save a billion dollars.

Mercedes-AMG GT S Driver Loses It, Hits The Sole Obstacle In Sight

When you have 730hp at your disposal, you’d better know how to handle them, or else…

Lamborghini Huracan Performante Posts 7:07.99 Lap At The ‘Ring

The unofficial run shows once again, if anyone needed proof, that the Lamborghini Huracan Performante is one impressive machine.

$90k Bespoke Land Rover Defender Pickup Is Ready For The Armageddon

The Chelsea Truck Company and Kahn Design are behind this wild project, which is for sale in the UK.

Chinese Buyers Hate New Car Smell, So Ford Wants To Eliminate It By Baking Its Cars

Much to our surprise, not everyone likes the new car smell.

2018 LA Auto Show: A-to-Z Guide To All The Product Launches

Join us for a tour of the Los Angeles Auto Show with a full guide to all the new cars.

Think All-Wheel Drive Crossovers Don’t Need Winter Tires? Think Again

A recent test shows winter tires improve traction, acceleration and braking on ice.

2019 Lexus UX Has Everything It Needs To Become A Hit In The U.S.

Lexus’ first-ever small SUV has a lot of features that’ll help it fight its premium rivals.

Volvo Stumps Us With Odd Teaser Campaign For LA Auto Show

Volvo is teasing something for LA, but we’re not entirely sure what.

2019 Mercedes-AMG G63 Combines Classic Looks And 577 HP For $147,500

Fans with smaller budgets can opt for the 2019 G 550 which has a base price of $124,500.

Cadillac Name-Drops The Escala, Is It A Hint About Production?

Previous reports have suggested the concept could go into production in 2021.