Elon Musk And SEC Told By Federal Judge To “Be Reasonable, Work It Out”

Tesla chief executive Elon Musk and the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) have been told by a federal judge to come to an agreement regarding the former’s use of Twitter.

Appearing at a federal court in New York, Musk was the center of attention as a judge heard oral arguments in a lawsuit brought forward by the SEC asking for him to be held in contempt for violating a settlement reached last September.

Judge Alison Nathan heard arguments from both sides, with the SEC claiming Musk is in “clear violation” of his agreement for not having tweets authorized before they are published. Musk’s lawyers argued that he had not violated the terms of the agreement.

The judge told the two parties to “take a deep breath, put their reasonable pants on and work it out.” She gave the parties two weeks to talk and come back to the court with an agreement, The Guardian reports.

Musk reached an agreement with the SEC in October after infamously tweeting that he had the funds in place to take Tesla private – which was proven to be inaccurate. As part of the agreement, Musk was to have any tweets with “material” information about Tesla pre-approved by a board established specifically to oversee his Twitter use.

On February 9, Musk appeared to violate this settlement when he tweeted that “Tesla made 0 cars in 2011, but will make around 500k in 2019.” He later corrected himself saying annualized production would likely be “around” 500,000 cars by the end of the year, with deliveries totaling 400,000 units

According to professor of corporate governance at the University of Delaware, Charles Elson, “the issue isn’t that he corrected the tweet, it’s that he was supposed to get approval before he did it and he did not. He breached the settlement, so the SEC can do whatever they wish.”

Briefly speaking with the media after his appearance in court, Musk said he was “very happy with the results and very impressed with Judge Nathan’s analysis.”


  • no25

    Elon Musk being reasonable? lol good luck

    • John Smith

      SEC investigating real financial crime? Good luck.

  • Mr. EP9

    Have fun with that. We all know that’s not going to happen. I expect that this will end before the judge again after neither side reaches an agreement.

  • Jason Miller

    Just leave the guy alone.

  • Dude

    The judge sounds like a tired parent

  • Harry_Wild

    SEC should force Elon Musk to resign his executive role and if he refuses charge him with disobeying the SEC orders. Send him to Federal prison for 25 years without parole!

    • illogicalPotato

      Wow, What world do you live in?

Someone Created A Tesla Model 3 Low-Rider Because Why Not?

A low-rider electric sedan ain’t something you see on a daily basis, but with the proliferation of EVs, maybe we should get start getting used to it.

Ford Is Reportedly Developing A Focus-Based Ute In Australia

Code-named the P758, it is expected to target the South American market, though it could be sold elsewhere as well.

Hyundai’s Pickup Could Get A Ranger Raptor-Rivaling Variant

A Hyundai pickup with the i30 N’s 2.0-liter turbo four-cylinder and close to 300 HP could be very fun indeed.

This Chevy Camaro Has Turned To The Dark Side, Sith Lords Don’t Approve

Underneath this badly executed body kit, which comes bundled with all sorts of unusual add-ons, lies a sixth-gen Camaro.

V8-Powered Ford Fusion With 450 HP And RWD Is The Closest Thing To A Mustang Sedan

Not content with the stock 325 HP twin-turbo V6, the owner of this saloon fitted a tuned Coyote engine and a 2007 ‘Stang GT500 transmission.

Kevin Hart’s Plymouth Barracuda Crash Investigated By Californian Authorities

The California Highway Patrol may recommend modified cars like Hart’s are fitted with five-point safety harnesses.

2020 Genesis G90 Vs. 2019 Mercedes S-Class: Underdog Takes On Top Dog

The 2020 G90 is fantastic value for money, but is it good enough to take on the luxury segment’s benchmark?.

Here’s a Close Look At The ID.3, Volkswagen’s Most Important New Car In Many Decades

The all-new compact electric hatchback is available in three different battery and electric motor configurations.

Mercedes SL 73 AMG: Rarer Than A Pagani Zonda And The Coolest R129 Of Them All

If you like 1990s AMGs, this SL 73 is the pick of the decade, packing a healthy 525 HP and being made in no more than 50 examples .

What Is BMW Testing With This M8 Prototype At The Nurburgring?

One possibility is that it’s an even more hardcore variant of the Competition, and another that the rear wing is going to be offered as an M Performance part.