For $250k, Which Of These Hardcore V8 Ferraris Would You Choose?

We’re just a few days away from RM Sotheby’s Monaco sale, where some very tantalizing machinery will be auctioned off to the highest bidder. Among them are these two silver (pardon us, “Argento Nurburgring”) Ferraris. And looking at them both, we can’t help but wonder which we’d choose.

The sequential precursors to today’s 488 Pista, the 360 Challenge Stradale and 430 Scuderia were the first two models in Maranello’s line of hardcore eight-cylinder supercars. They were evolutions of the same, with V8 engines, track-tuned suspensions, and little else that wasn’t strictly necessary.

Their cockpits were stripped out. Their glass windows (though not the windshield) were replaced with plexi. The manual option forgone in favor of paddle shifters. The brakes replaced by carbon-ceramic rotors. And their engines were each boosted by 20 horsepower.

Further evolved, the 430 was the quicker and more powerful of the two. Its 4.3-liter atmospheric V8 was tuned to deliver 503 horsepower (375 kW) and 350 lb-ft (470 Nm) of torque. It could hit 62 mph (100 km/h) in 3.7 seconds, and top out at 196 mph (315 km/h). The 360, by comparison, produced relatively less at 420 hp (313 kW) and 275 lb-ft (373 Nm) of torque), so it took an even 4.0 seconds to reach 60 and maxed out at 176 mph (283 km/h). But to our eyes, the Challenge Stradale remains the better-looking of the two… even if it was (relatively) slower.

Delivered to then-Ferrari chief (now FIA president) Jean Todt, the 360 CS has had three more owners over its lifetime. Between them, they’ve put 22,000 miles (35,500 kilometers) on it. The auctioneer values it between €190k and €210k (or about $225-250k). The 430 Scuderia, on the other hand, has only 2,000 km (1,242 miles) on the clock, and is estimated to sell for €200-240k (~$240-285k). The same ballpark, essentially. So if you had to choose between the two, which would you take?

more photos...

Photos courtesy of RM Sotheby’s

more photos...

Photos by Kevin Van Campenhout, courtesy of RM Sotheby’s

  • Infinite1

    The 360 Challenge Stradale is still beautiful but I’d have to go with the Scuderia

  • Shahul Usman

    challenge.. sounds sooo good.. more raw.. I also think it’s design aged better than the 430’s

  • Nordschleife

    The Challenge Stradale is like my favorite name so I’d pick that.

  • Would love other mid engined V8 Ferrari, the F40…. But then I realized they are double price than these cars.

  • LWOAP

    360 Challenge Stradale or 430 Scuderia?

    That’s just not fair. I can’t choose one.

  • Thunderbolt

    430 easy choice.

  • Antonio

    The Scuderia with the 360 rims….

  • Balcis

    When 430 came out, I couldn’t believe how much of it is copied and every bit of styling is inspired from enzo. This car is exact middle of 360 and enzo. Ratios from 360, and all the styling from enzo.

  • Six_Tymes

    hmmm, ill let you know when i hit the lottery. so, dont hold your breath

  • Vassilis

    Easily the 430. Better car.

BMW Unlikely To Chase Mercedes-AMG’s A45 S With 1-Series M Hatch

The BMW 1-Series range will likely be topped out by the M135i.

2020 Mercedes GLA Compact Crossover Is The A-Class You’ll Most Likely Buy

The new generation of the popular Mercedes GLA is rumored to debut at the Frankfurt Motor Show.

Bowlus Road Chief ‘Endless Highways’ Is A $185k Retro Travel Trailer Bathed In Chrome

The Bowlus Road Chief ‘Endless Highways’ will set you back $185,000.

Kia Driver Cuts Off Rider Who Lands On Hood, Then Angrily Smashes Windshield

Even though the driver was at fault, the rider had plenty of time to take evasive action.

Netflix’s Animated ‘Fast & Furious’ Series Is Coming, Here’s The Trailer

Fast & Furious: Spy Racers will be focused on the cousin of Dominic Toretto.

Is The 2020 Ford Explorer As Good As The Figures Suggest?

The new Ford Explorer sounds impressive on paper but now it’s time to find out what it’s like on the real world.

Tesla Arcade Launches With Beach Buggy Racing 2

Tesla’s new Beach Buggy Racing 2 game will make charging that much more enjoyable.

2020 BMW Z4 M40i Delivers Some Mighty Impressive Figures On The Dyno

This 2020 BMW Z4 M40i pumped out 373 hp through the rear wheels.

Mercedes-AMG GT R Roadster Commands A £30,000 Premium Over The Coupe In UK

The new Mercedes roadster comes with 577hp and a 197mph top speed.

Renault Triber Sub-4-Meter SUV Unveiled With Seating For 7

The Renault Triber is limited to the Indian market and is powered by a small Dacia engine.