The Case For And Against Three-Car Formula One Teams

Breaking through in the world of Formula 1 isn’t as easy as some young drivers make it look, as there are still plenty of talented names left on the sidelines every year.

Youngsters such as F2 championship leader George Russell are in a bit of a limbo as Mercedes have failed to secure him an F1 seat for 2019 as of right now. Current Force India driver Esteban Ocon is in a similar situation, as his spot will likely go to Lance Stroll next season.

Of course, this could all be a non-issue if the FIA simply allowed for more cars to be placed on the grid.

The concept of three-car teams is nothing new. F1 has been toying with the idea for quite some time and back in the days of customer cars, like in the 60s and 70s, teams were lining up four or even five cars during races.

So then should this trend be allowed to cycle back? According to F2’s George Russell, who told Autosport that F1 is “currently lacking at least two teams”, it definitely should.

“We only have 20 cars on the grid, as a young driver trying to break into that 20 is extremely difficult,” said Russell. “I think the idea of a third car, or something along those lines, is a very good idea.”

“You sometimes see the pay drivers getting into Formula 1, and potentially they could come in for their home race: an Asian driver comes in for the Asian races, the American drivers come in for the American races and so on. It gives the likes of Mercedes, Ferrari and Red Bull the chance to throw their young drivers in without any major issues.”

Not so fast, George

On the opposite side of the spectrum are people such as Haas team principal Gunther Steiner, who thinks a third car would cause a distortion in the standings and confuse fans.

“I’m not in agreement with a third car because it would confuse the whole picture,” said Steiner. “It would be very difficult to understand for the fans and new spectators that sometimes a third car could run. It would distort the actual championship, in my opinion. I think we need to sit back and come up with a better idea.”

“As it stands, we have no interest to field a third car. If somebody comes up and pays for it, yes we can consider it.”

We actually understand where Steiner is coming from. A midfield team such as Haas would struggle to secure strong grid positions if it had to battle even more cars fielded by the likes of Ferrari, Mercedes and Red Bull. Financially though, it probably wouldn’t be that big of an issue, as George Russell will happily point out.

“Formula 1 is an extremely expensive sport because of the development, not because of the actual cost of building the front wings or whatever. The money is spent in the wind tunnels, on designers’ salaries, the time and effort to design the cars. To make three wings instead of two is not going to be a huge additional cost. [Or] a third chassis compared to two.”

In the end, this seems to be more of a competitive issue than a financial one. A young driver employed by Mercedes such as Russell would obviously love to find himself on the grid, behind the wheel of a Mercedes. But what if you’re trying to break through behind the wheel of a car that’s currently under-performing such as a Williams? You would have to fight through even more superior cars to get in the top 10.

In fact, you could argue that Mercedes, Ferrari and Red Bull could secure the top 9 positions during races with ease, barring any incidents. That doesn’t sound like a lot of fun, does it?

more photos...
  • Matthew Boyd

    Highly against, let’s not waste more money as the cost of F1 needs to go down to begin with.

  • Kagan

    Have just one car per team so they can’t cheat!

2020 Porsche 718 Cayman GT4 Meets 991 GT2 RS, 997 GT3 RS For A Tire-Slaying Fest

How does the new 718 Cayman GT4 compare to two of the finest 911s Porsche’s GT division has ever created?.

2019 Mercedes-Benz CLA: Mini CLS Or Sleeker Alternative To The A-Class?

The new CLA is a good daily driver and a quality item, so if you don’t mind the cramped back seat, go for it.

It’ll Cost You $26k To Make Your Vantage Look Like This, Get An Extra 90 Horses

While the price does seem steep, bear in mind that this is a $150k Aston, and the list consists of quite a few upgrades.

Suzuki Jimny Shows Its Off-Roading Prowess Against A Triumph Scrambler

With a mere 101 HP, power is not the Jimny’s strong suit. It’s off-road capabilities, though, are, but do they suffice against the Triumph?.

CARB Filing Reveals Rolls-Royce Cullinan Will Get Black Badge Variant

Judging by other Rolls models that have received the same treatment, we know what to expect; the only unknown is whether it’ll get a power bump or not.

Alpina Has No Interest Tuning BMW’s Front-Wheel Drive Models

Alpina says it would be hard to make money from pumped-up versions of Munich’s latest FWD crop of cars.

This Ferrari 308 GTB Is An Enthusiast’s Dream Come True

It might not be the best, most reliable or fastest Ferrari, but for one person who was in love with it for a long time, it’s bliss.

Next-Generation Fiat Panda To Gain All-Electric Variant In 2023

The Panda EV will closely resemble the Centoventi concept and will adopt its swappable and upgradeable battery pack.

Mercedes-AMG G63 Proclaimed The Most Desirable Big SUV In The World

It’s still a great off-roader, has a modern, luxurious cabin, lots of power and can even tackle a track, so what’s not to love?.

If Toyota Were To Revive The MR2, It’d Rather Do It With Porsche

How does a mid-engine platform for a new MR2 and next-gen Boxster sound?.