Study Shows Britain’s Worst Drivers Own German Premium Cars

If you come across a posh German car in the UK, odds are its driver is a lot more likely to scare you than, say, someone behind the wheel of a Japanese or Italian model.

These numbers come directly from GoCompare Car Insurance, who looked into which drivers are statistically the most dangerous on UK roads. Apparently, the worst were those driving BMW 4-Series models, specifically the 420d, as reported by Cornwall Live.

According to the study, 420d drivers are the most likely to be convicted of an offense, as well as most likely to cause a collision on the road.

While BMW drivers top this list, people who own Mercedes and Audi models aren’t far behind. In terms of actual convictions, here’s how the top 10 shapes up: BMW 420d (17.1%), Audi A5 (15.5%), Mercedes C220 (14.8%), Mercedes E220 (14.8%), Jaguar XF (14.3%), Mercedes CLA (14.3%), Mercedes GLC (14.0%), Audi Q7 (13.8%), Land Rover Range Rover (13.8%) and Mercedes CLS (13.5%).

On the opposite side of the spectrum is the Vauxhall Agila at 4.1%, followed by the Hyundai i10 (4.3%), Nissan Micra (4.4%), Kia Picanto (4.4%), Hyundai Getz (4.5%), Suzuki Alto (4.6%), Ford Ka (4.6%), Skoda Citigo (4.7%), Honda Jazz (4.8%) and the Fiat Panda (4.9%).

When it comes to fault claims, the numbers tell a slightly different story, although not by much. The BMW 420d is still the main culprit at 21.3%, followed by the Mercedes E220 (19.3%), Mercedes GLC (19.3%), Audi A5 (19.1%), Audi Q5 (18.7%), Mercedes C220 (18.6%), Mercedes GLA (18.3%), Jaguar XF (18.2%), Audi A1 (18.2%) and the Skoda Superb (18.1%).

The models with the least amount of claims are the Peugeot 206 at 8.6%, Hyundai Getz (9.0%), Citroen C2 (9.0%), Nissan Almera (9.2%), Fiat Punto (9.6%), Peugeot 307 (9.9%), Ford Ka (10.0%), Citroen Xsara (10.1%), Nissan Micra (10.3%) and the Vauxhall Agila (10.3%).

“While it may be no surprise that higher-powered luxury cars are the marques of choice for some of the most dangerous drivers on the road, it’s not true of all owners of this makes,” stated Matt Oliver, spokesperson for GoCompare Car Insurance. “What is more worrying is the large number of these cars on the road right now. According to data from the Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders (SMMT), BMW, Mercedes and Audi all feature among the top ten most popular cars of 2018.”

“Typically, many of the cars listed in our top ten lists will be driven by those commuting or driving for longer periods on the motorway, at peak times in highly built-up areas, increasing the risk of an accident or motoring conviction. Claiming on insurance when you’re at fault is likely to result in the cost of your car insurance rocketing, more so than other claims, as you will be deemed a higher-risk driver.”

more photos...
  • Loquacious Borborygmus

    Hmmm, I am not so sure that aunt Ethel in her Vauxhall Agila is a shit hot driver.

    • R55

      Yeh, every time I see an Agila they’re 15mph below the speed limit 😆

    • Marty

      That’s maybe because you, like for example many BMW drivers, have misunderstood what it means to be a good driver.

      • Loquacious Borborygmus

        Can you please tell me what is required?

        • Marty

          Certainly. The minimum requirement, which this article concerns, is to reach our destination without causing accidents and breaking laws.

          (And no, a person that is in our way when we want to drive over the speed limit is not causing the accident. That’s also a common misconception. By the way, these kinds of statistics usually show the same results in single car accidents. The ones we can’t blame on Ethel.)

          • Loquacious Borborygmus

            Well done you for assuming that I was infering speed was old aunt Ethel’s problem.
            You know what they say about assume, don’t you?

  • iea96

    What a surprise

  • Charles Chin

    Does driving a Rangie makes someone a lesser snob?

    • FlameWater

      From my experience Range Rover drivers are far worse and more dangerous considering the size and power of their vehicle.

  • ➡️ProtectOurHeritage⬅️

    Nice advert for Go Compare. Another report I read claimed it was Jaguar drivers.

    • Loquacious Borborygmus

      Yeah, those Jagwar drivers…

  • Bash

    Well the 420 IS a bad number.

  • Bo Hanan

    Define “worst?”

    • Marty

      Read the article. 🙂

  • Kate E

    Women in BMWs are the worst

  • Richard Alexander

    Not sure about the UK but here in the US premium European vehicles are very popular with Asians……..

  • Bob White

    IT doesn’t help that Brits are always drunk… Lol

2020 Ford Explorer Prices Bumped Up From $400 To $8,115

The Blue Oval has considerably updated the Explorer, but it does charge a premium for it.

Kia Niro EV Vs. Rivals: See How Entry-Level Battery Electrics Stack Up

The entry-level electric vehicle segment is booming, so we compare five new and upcoming models.

2019 Mazda6 Is A Quality Saloon That Will Make You Feel Special

Stylish, comfortable and with good handling, the Mazda6 can give premium models a good scare.

Somehow, The Driver Of This Cruze Made It Out With Minor Injuries!

It may be hard to believe, yet whoever was driving the Cruze thankfully escaped almost unharmed .

Chevy Dealers Snap Up All 2019 Colorado ZR2 Bisons – And They’re Flying Off Lots

Despite a nearly $50k price tag, this year’s production of the Colorado ZR2 Bison is already allocated to dealers.

Car Monitoring Tech Learns Your Passengers’ Age, Gender And A Whole Lot More

“My car is my castle” could soon become “My car is a 24-hour Big Brother AI”.

Buick Cascada Getting Axed, Will Be Missed By No One

GM finally admitted that Buick’s first convertible in 25 years won’t be sold beyond 2019.

Should You Spend £43,000 On Skoda’s 237 HP Kodiaq RS?

The Kodiaq RS is pretty good, but is it nearly $50k good? Watch this review to find out.

Land Rover Kills Plans For Discovery SVX Hardcore Off-Roader

JLR has already announced that it would reduce its model count, and the Disco SVX project was axed.

GM’s eBike Brand Named ARĪV, Launches In Europe With Two Models

The Meld and Merge eBikes offer ranges of up to 64 km (40 miles) on a single charge.