- Fraud linked to the privatization of the vehicle registration system.
- Weak oversight allowed fake companies to access official databases.
- Around 1 million vehicles may now have questionable registrations.
France has been hit by a major scandal that has reportedly seen a million vehicles end up with illegal registrations. Cars registered illegally have cost the French government millions of dollars in taxes and fines, as individuals misregistered cars, altered documents for stolen vehicles, and avoided paying road fines such as speeding tickets.
It’s because of a 2017 decision to part-privatize the registration system. This allowed dealerships to directly access the registration system, but was reportedly too reliant on self-regulation.
Vulnerabilities Exploited
The reason why France computerized car registration was to ensure that the process was quicker. However, according to a warning issued by the Cour des comptes, the state audit office in France, this was the largest weakness of the system too: it had open doors.
With partial reliance on a private middleman and subsequent laxity in timely overseeing matters, law enforcement agencies provided space to offer ghost registrations: where a vehicle was able to circulate and those registering it were difficult to trace.
Read: These New Pink License Plates Aren’t For Show, They’re A Warning Sign
Close to one million vehicles were registered using about 300 fake companies, approximately 1.7 percent of the national fleet. The money trail is also a cause of concern. According to the report, this loss is estimated to be over 550 million between 2022 and 2024, and this loss only includes the unpaid fines and the unpaid registration taxes to the state and to the regions.
When the procedure of registering cars was transferred to online websites through certified professionals who could use the SIV registration database, theoretically, such operators would cross-verify documents and identities and make correct submissions of files.
The BBC reports that networks of fraud benefited by exploiting that loophole to set up shell businesses that seemingly transpired in the system, but did not actually exist. With approval of an account, there is an opportunity to get vehicles registered in large numbers by means of them. That allowed a Swiss cheese way of covering up the true ownership, passing ticket to a carrier that is paper-only and cover the trail in case the police or the insurers were trying to find out the ownership.
Also: EU’s 2035 EV-Only Dream Hits A Hybrid Speed Bump
Damage is larger than revenue loss, according to investigators. The unreliability in registration information kills the normal enforcement. The notices of speeding, tolls, and parking fines can be posted in a dead end. Offenders can safeguard their license points by ensuring that they do not have violations under their name. Laundering stolen vehicles through the same mediums can also be done through provision of a new identity to the vehicles that seem to be official.
Another temptation is also made by ordinary drivers: to give money to a middleman who guarantees them rapid outcome and less headaches. When the service is involved with a bogus garage, this can help make the registry a kind of shield, rather than a record.
The Cour des Comptes claims that the state needs to exert a stronger grip on the gate. It suggests increased vetting before accessing database, regular verification of high-volume operators, quicker cessation of suspicious objects, and enhanced IT protection such that a single mailbox firm does not perform thousands of registrations.
