Mercedes A-Class Old Vs New: Is The CLS-Like Styling Working For You?

Ever since Mercedes had a change of heart concerning the A-Class nameplate and made it a traditional C-segment hatchback, the latter has gone from sporty and dramatic to elegant and high-tech.

As most of you probably recall, the A-Class wasn’t always a 5-door compact car able to rival the likes of the BMW 1-Series or the Audi A3. The first two generations were sub-compact and more like a mini MPV, what with that “clever” sandwich platform and all.

However, in 2012, the German automaker launched the third generation, code-named W176, that was previewed by the Concept A-Class unveiled at the Shanghai Auto Show a year before. It was an attempt to lure in younger buyers with a dynamic and stylish product, featuring more aggressive design elements than any of its direct rivals.

Three years later, in the summer of 2015, Mercedes came out with the facelifted version, adding a revised engine range, subtly tweaked exterior, an upgraded infotainment system with a larger 8″ display, revamped seats, better materials and so on.

The fourth-generation A-Class that was unveiled last week is quite a bit different. Not only is it a lot more advanced technologically, it’s also simpler in its design, and thus more elegant, at least according to Mercedes. During the launch event, company chairman Dieter Zetsche admitted that the goal for the third-generation car was to stand out as much as possible, whereas this newer model is more grown up.

 

It features a progressive front-end design with a low bonnet and flat LED headlights, larger wheel arches, slimmer taillights and a sharper profile, whereas the interior is a lot more modern thanks to the massive MBUX dual-touchscreen layout, as well as the ambient lighting that’s available and lets you choose between 64 colors.

The new A-Class has also grown in size, boasting a longer wheelbase and a wider track. This results in more shoulder, elbow and head room. Also, the previous car wasn’t particularly known for rear seat roominess or a soft ride for that matter. The new model is supposed to solve all that, even the ride issue, but we’ll have to wait for the first reviews to come in to confirm that.

Since this is a visual comparison, we’re mostly interested in hearing what you think about the new A-Class and if you believe its new interior and exterior styling represent a significant improvement over the older car or not. Voice off in the comments section below.

 

Old Vs New Mercedes-Benz A-Class

  • Nordschleife

    I prefer the new especially in the interior. The previous A-Class (or current) looks bulbous to me. I think the new versions details make it look more refined and assertive.

    • ToniCipriani ✓pǝᴉɟᴉɹǝʌ

      Losing the Garmin helped with the looks immensely.

      • wait a minute

        I think they’re on a role with their new big screen. It’s just gone into the new G-Wagon, and will probably be in their Sprinter Vans next- One size fits all. Credit to their design team who cracked it.

  • Obsequious Lickspittle

    Too generic for me. That back end will sure give A3 owners a tough choice come buying time.

    • no25

      people dont buy cars based on what the back end looks like lmao

      • SteersUright

        Quite a few decisions in life are made based on what a “back end” looks like 😉

        • Six Thousand Times

          Holiday on Fire Island again? 😉

        • Bash

          Gold!

      • Status

        That’s why Zagato cars look as bad as they do.

      • Obsequious Lickspittle

        Whoosh

        • Six Thousand Times

          Doesn’t a joke have to actually be a joke for it to go over someone’s head? Just asking.

          • Obsequious Lickspittle

            It does. However, I wasn’t making a joke.

  • SteersUright

    The new one is definitely a better design but still not a good looking vehicle. It looks too much like a lowered SUV/crossover thing rather than a proper sporting hot hatch. The rear tail lights, large front overhang, effeminate front design, tall bulgy hood, small wheel to body ratio, and the arc in the bottom of the window framing rather than a confident straight line are the major flaws that work against this being any kind of beauty. That said, I have yet to see a beautiful hot-hatch ever, so the title is still up for grabs!

  • supermanuel

    Like the new one a lot, much better resolved than the current one (and the BMW 1) and infinitely more interesting than the blandmobile A3. Let’s not even mention the embarrassingly odd CT. There are obviously bits that I think could do with improvement but it’s a good step forward from the last one.

  • rodriguez256

    I like everything about the new model besides the front end. It’s mainly the headlights that ruin it.

  • europeon

    I like the tail lights. They suit the car’s rear end.

    Anyway, this is the only kind of articIe that ST does right. More like this, less aftermarket rims and BMW advertorials.

    • gor134

      Spoke to soon man… another BMW post 🙁

    • Six Thousand Times

      Fewer aftermarket rims but your point is valid.

    • gor134

      Wtf my comment got removed..

  • Julien Lachemoi

    It would be perfect if it wasn’t for the head and rear lights.
    The inside though is a big improvement.

  • rover10

    The current car has lost too much character especially the rear. Gone is the frowning rear spoiler, which glared at you as it past. The front end has also lost its magic a bit, but it’s the nubbed off bodyside that disappoints most. The well rubbed bar of soap design signature, currently being rolled out on new models, will I’m sure cause some debate within the Mercedes buying public?

  • Six_Tymes

    that dash is great design, BUT i am already over the Jet Engine blade looking vents, those need to go. Imagine that dash design, with a streamlined vent design like the model 3, it would be a perfect dash

    • Matt

      No the vents stay.

      • Six_Tymes

        No they go

  • sidewaysspin

    Outside it looks worse but the inside is a quantum leap forward.

  • no25

    do you even know what “i.e.” is for?

    • Six Thousand Times

      He was looking for “ergo,” I’d reckon.

  • Ilbirs

    The side profiles show how much room in the current gen is being eaten by the bigger wheel wells.

  • Mynameis Taylor

    I think this never version looks so much better and sleeker from every angle. I hated the proportions of the previous model. The interior design and style is a vast improvement. I’d totally buy it

  • S3XY

    No.

  • Old exterior, new interior for me

    • wait a minute

      i agree the old model had a more dynamic sportier exterior, but now the the new model follows the latest design language of mercedes benz. In other words its conforming with the current design direction especially CLS and GT style models.

  • Six Thousand Times

    Those dull “satin?” finishes never look good to me. I likes me new motors shiny. It looks like Merc’ve reduced the front overhang, which is always good, and gotten rid of that crazy line that shoots up and bisects the rear doors.

  • YUDHA BAGASKARA

    interior is the best in the new generation
    i still prefer old exterior as side profile is too similar with renault megane

  • Vassilis

    Yeah the new one looks much better.

  • Honda NSX-R

    I like minimalistic approach for the interior. The exterior changes are welcome too

  • Toronado_II

    I hate that screen. Doesn’t look like a car dashboard anymore…

  • haudit

    I think it’s old exterior, new interior for me. The new car has exterior design elements I like, such as the rear lights, but the shape of the DLO doesn’t seem as natural or smooth as the older model.

  • Rich Money

    the old grille was better. the new headlights are better.
    the old dashboard was solid. the new one is the future.
    the bodyside sculpting on the new one is superior.
    the profiles are roughly identical.
    its a solid step forward, propelled by the new space-age dashboard.

  • Six_Tymes

    could be so much better, if the mars wheels where not inside the cabin.
    https://uploads.disquscdn.com/images/9d8142ad0a0354437c22600a25820f0f4399f5651d59b562a9691bfea5017d4b.jpg

1,200 HP Jeep Grand Cherokee SRT8 Makes The Trackhawk Seem Puny

It may be seven years old, but this wildly modified Grand Cherokee is one of the craziest Jeeps out there.

Olympic Athlete Runs In A Bubble Filled With Hyundai Nexo’s Exhaust Flow

The Nexo’s exhaust emits water and 99.9 per cent filtered oxygen – or else the runner would suffocate.

Lunaz Breathes New Life Into Classics With Electric Power And Modern Gear

After a full restoration process, the old mechanical parts are ditched in favor of all-electric powertrains and tech like Wi-Fi .

Totally Burnt Out Ferrari 458 Spider Is Unrecognizable, Yet Up For Sale

Nothing in this pile reminds us of a 458, as it’s been completely destroyed, but someone has decided to put it up for auction.

Goddammit! Delivery Guy Tries To Slice Half A Second Off, Instantly Regrets It

The truck driver apparently pushed the gas pedal instead of the brake.

Driven: 2019 Toyota 86 GT Remains A Compelling Driver’s Car

The Toyota 86 GT with the Dynamic Performance Package is a hoot to drive, despite showing its age in certain areas.

Mazda Continues Testing RX-8 Prototypes At The ‘Ring, Fuels Rotary Return Rumors

Could Mazda bring back the RX nameplate that was killed off in 2012, probably with some kind of electrification? We sure hope so.

Legends Reborn: Restoration Brings Mercedes-Benz 190 E 2.3-16 Racer Back To Its Former Glory

Originally a DTM racer, the Mercedes-Benz 190 E 2.3-16 competed in the 1986 Bathurst 1000, winning it in 1990.

2020 Mazda CX-30: Where Does It Stand In The Already Crowded SUV Market?

The CX-30 is eye-catching, well made and a lot of car for the money, but fails to offer an engaging driving experience.

ABT Gives Europe’s 2020 Audi S5 Sportback A Diesel Boost To 379 HP

The tuning package is available for both the facelifted S5 Sportback and the TDI-powered pre-facelift model.