New York City Says Its Saved A Ton Of Money With Its Electric Vehicle Fleet

As the prices of electric vehicles continue to fall, many expect them to slowly take over the automotive market in the coming decades.

At least one recent study suggests that electric vehicles will reach price parity with gas and diesel vehicles by 2024. However, for some fleet operators, EVs can already be more cost effective to operate in large numbers than ICE vehicles.

Quartz reports that the New York City government has been adding a number of electric vehicles to its fleet. While these cars often cost more to buy, figures show that they have significantly lower maintenance costs.

Data via Atlas

“NYC Fleet has more experience with electric vehicles than most, so we took a look at last year’s maintenance costs with the DCAS client fleet to see if these service benefits are materializing,” reads a New York City Fleet Newsletter sent earlier this month. “Right now, servicing costs with our all-electric vehicle models is dramatically less than with gas, hybrid, or hybrid plug-in models. In general, our hybrid models also achieve benefits from gas models, though the most dramatic results in this report are with the all electrics.”

Data released by New York City’s fleet management agency shows that in 2018, Chevrolet Bolts in the city’s fleet had average maintenance costs of $205. The Nissan Leaf and electric Ford Focus followed closely behind with $344 and $386 respectively in maintenance costs. At the other end of the spectrum sits the gas-powered Ford Focus, with $1,805.

“All early indicators are that we are achieving the fuel, emissions, and maintenance benefits of this exciting transition away from the internal combustion engine,” the agency wrote.

When compared to a gas Ford Fusion, the Leaf costs almost $3,000 more, with a $25,797 price tag compared to the $22,866 of the Fusion. However, whereas the Fusion uses $765 worth of fuel per year, the Leaf uses $141 worth of electricity. The EV also has significantly lower maintenance costs and, despite requiring a $2,656 charger, may only cost the city $32,580 over a period of nine years. By comparison, the Fusion has an expected cost of $41,328 over the same time period.

more photos...
  • Super Rob

    The EV’s definitely have a huge advantage in maintenance and simplicity. When the recharge times catch up the switch over will be very quick.

    • Six_Tymes


      I do wonder if in my life time ill see steady, fast full charge times. same as a filling up a empty 15 gallon tank of gas for example.

      • Super Rob

        In 15 years every 7-11 and Circle K will have “electric pumps”. Standardized pump and fast enough charge times. The solid state battery will arrive and change everything. Toyota and Panasonic are working on some fast stuff. No one really looked/cared about batteries before. Now with cars and storing energy from solar, it’s become a big deal.

  • Richard Alexander

    Part of the answer: the empoyees aren’t using them commute to their homes 2 hours north of the city daily, like they notoriously do with the ICE vehicles…. God I LOVE paying for that….but my taxes aren’t high enough….

  • jon4uu

    I’ve had 2 Volts for the last 6 years and I can’t for the life of me figure how they spent 1,210 dollars a year on maintenance. The engine requires nothing but oil changes for the first 100K and my car needs those only every 2 years or about every 25K. I wonder if they even bothered plugging them in. They probably ran them on the gas motor and most of the money was spent on that? Interesting

  • Dude


  • rockyroad

    That’s good sign of change in effort to lower human’s global pollution. However, there is still a significant amount of emission being produced with vehicles and transportation alone and that should never have continued. The impact our innocent commutes may suggest.

  • This is a perfect explanation why plug-ins sound great in theory but are a terrible idea in reality. They barely work as an EV, but you double the complexity and end up paying a lot for servicing.

  • Sukhoi31m3

    EVs are just getting started good. If EV cars had the over 100 years of development the ICE has had, they just might “fill up” faster than a 15 gallon gas tank. With more and more cities, counties and countries looking to phase out gas / diesel powered vehicles, I suspect we’ll soon see more development dollars diverted to battery powertrains while the ICE is left to whither on the vine.

  • robotlogic

    New York city saving money? Right, that’s funny!!! Tell us another one.

18-Year-Old Charged With DUI Smashes Lamborghini Gallardo Into Two Vehicles

The crash was so loud it made some mistake it for an explosion or something.

Maserati Quattroporte L’Ultimo Concept Is Italian Luxury At Its Finest

This futuristic Maserati Quattroporte render stays (mosty) true to the current model’s design language.

Lexus Safety System+ To Be Standard Equipment On All 2020 Models

The safety suite includes automatic high beam headlights, adaptive cruise control and a a pre-collision system.

Porsche North America Boss Says EVs Will Soon Become Commonplace

Porsche is confident it can easily out-sell its first year of production of the upcoming Taycan .

2020 MINI Electric Teased, Debuts July 9th

MINI is going electric, but the upcoming Cooper SE is only expected to have a range of approximately 114 miles.

Korean Brands Dominate Initial Quality Study, But Porsche’s 911 Comes Out On Top

Genesis had the highest initial quality and they were closely followed by Kia and Hyundai.

Ford Says Explorer ST Customers Aren’t Interested In A V8

The hottest Explorer on sale is powered by an EcoBoost 3.0-liter V6 with 400 HP.

SUV And Tow Truck Decide To Go Their Separate Ways

After the SUV fell off, the tow truck began rolling forward towards a parked van.

2020 Cadillac XT5 Facelift Bows In China With Minor Updates

The 2020 Cadillac XT5 has a new grille and an updated infotainment system with a rotary controller.

Spiderman Goes Electric, Takes A Spin In The Audi E-tron GT

The latest Spiderman flick will feature cameos by the Audi A7, Q8 and e-tron.