Chris Harris Compares Lexus GS F To BMW M5 With Surprising Results

For many, even as its successor is almost here, the F10 BMW M5 remains the benchmark in its class, thanks to its excellent balance, rear-wheel drive antics and handling characteristics. So on paper, compared to something like the Lexus GS F, the old M5 has the advantage.

Yet, Top Gear’s Chris Harris didn’t let that stop him from driving these two cars back to back and arriving at a pretty surprising conclusion, one that favors the Lexus over the Bimmer in a pretty major way.

Just to make it clear, it has little to do with performance, since the M5, in this case the 30th Anniversary edition, puts down 600 PS (592 HP) and 700 Nm (516 lb-ft) of torque, reaching 100 km/h (62 mph) in 3.9 sec.

The GS F on the other hand needs 4.6 seconds to hit the mark, and is clearly down on power with 473 PS (467 HP) and just 527 Nm (389 lb-ft) of torque. But what the Lexus can’t do in terms of performance, it more than makes up for with its excellent seating position, howling naturally-aspirated engine note and ride quality, especially on a harsh road.

In the end, Harris praises the GS F for being “more enjoyable to drive, most of the time”, despite the M5 being an overall better performer.


  • donald seymour

    I’m glad to see my boy Neil is working with Top Gear.

  • Kyle Newberry

    Why can’t i find the M5 on BMW website either US or UK?

    • Jonathan Gonzalez Martinez

      Because the new m5 is not on sale yet. The one in the vídeo is the older gen m5.

  • Ameer Hassan Tajaldeen

    did i just watch a lexus commercial

    • Andrewthecarguy

      Yes you did.

  • Finkployd

    go lexus yayy 👏

  • Bash

    I so want the gsf in my garage… but, they discontinue it! 🙁

  • Andrewthecarguy

    I normally enjoy Chris Harris’ reviews.
    This on the other hand was paid for by Lexus.

Porsche North America Boss Says EVs Will Soon Become Commonplace

Porsche is confident it can easily out-sell its first year of production of the upcoming Taycan .

2020 MINI Electric Teased, Debuts July 9th

MINI is going electric, but the upcoming Cooper SE is only expected to have a range of approximately 114 miles.

Korean Brands Dominate Initial Quality Study, But Porsche’s 911 Comes Out On Top

Genesis had the highest initial quality and they were closely followed by Kia and Hyundai.

Ford Says Explorer ST Customers Aren’t Interested In A V8

The hottest Explorer on sale is powered by an EcoBoost 3.0-liter V6 with 400 HP.

SUV And Tow Truck Decide To Go Their Separate Ways

After the SUV fell off, the tow truck began rolling forward towards a parked van.

2020 Cadillac XT5 Facelift Bows In China With Minor Updates

The 2020 Cadillac XT5 has a new grille and an updated infotainment system with a rotary controller.

Spiderman Goes Electric, Takes A Spin In The Audi E-tron GT

The latest Spiderman flick will feature cameos by the Audi A7, Q8 and e-tron.

Acura To Tackle Pikes Peak With A 400 HP MDX Sport Hybrid

Acura is also bringing along four other models to the hillclimb, including two NSXs.

James Bond May Drive The Aston Martin Valhalla In New Film

The Valhalla will hit the streets in 2021 with a 1,000 hp hybrid powertrain.

Ferrari 488 Pista Laps The Top Gear Track In A Record 1:12.7

The Ferrari 488 Pista features a twin-turbo V8 with a brutal 711 hp and 568 lb-ft of torque.