E-Mails Show EPA Fought Government’s Claim Lower Fuel Economy Standards Would Save Lives

Earlier this month, the Environmental Protection Agency and the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration unveiled a proposal for freezing fuel economy standards at 2020 levels for cars and trucks built for the 2021-2026 model years.

A number of people were upset about the proposal as it meant automakers would only need to hit an average fuel economy rating of 37 mpg (44 mpg UK / 6.3L / 100km). This figure is far lower than Obama-era plan which called for a corporate average fuel economy rating of 54.5 mpg (65.4 mpg UK / 4.3L / 100km) by 2025.

The government attempted to explain the need for lower fuel economy standards by making the bizarre claim that the eased regulation would actually save lives. In fact, the proposal is officially called the “Safer Affordable Fuel-Efficient (SAFE) Vehicles Rule” and the government claimed the proposal is “anticipated to prevent thousands of on-road fatalities and injuries as compared to the standards set forth in the 2012 final rule.”

The government attempted to explain this thinking by saying that cars and trucks will be more affordable under new rule and, therefore, more people will buy them. The government also noted new cars are safer than old cars, so lives would be saved.

That’s a bit of leap, to say the least, and a new report from the Associated Press seems to contradict the government’s official stance. According to e-mails obtained by the news service, senior EPA staffers told the Office of Management and Budget that the new rules would actually increase fatalities instead of preventing them. As the EPA’s director of the assessments and standards division for the office of transportation and air quality said, the “proposed standards are detrimental to safety, rather than beneficial.”

If the EPA’s analysis is correct, the 17 more people would be killed every year under the new proposal. This is in stark contrast to the government’s claim that the proposal could save up to 1,000 lives annually.

The proposal has a long way to go before it becomes law and 19 states have joined forces to sue over the proposal.

  • Хиллари сосет киску

    Yawn… just keep gas prices low and all will be good.

  • cooper

    Winning? Well not for your kids and grand kids.

  • UH, HUH.

  • badcyclist

    There must be a digital sign hanging somewhere in the White House: “XX consecutive seconds without a lie.”

  • S3XY

    How disgusting. Few more months and I won’t be contributing any money to GM anymore.

  • Enter Ranting

    I’m sorry, you’ll have to call back later. The president has his hands full with Omorosa.

  • Emoto

    Another day, another hit piece aimed at an administration that dares to back away from something decided during the last administration’s reign of error.

2020 Honda HR-V Carries Over Unchanged Except For Higher Prices

Price increases for the 2020 Honda HR-V lineup range from $350 to $500.

China’s Denza X Electric SUV Is A Mercedes-Benz In All But Name

The styling of the Denza X midsize crossover stays remarkably close to the namesake concept that was unveiled earlier this year.

This 2020 Toyota Supra Didn’t Even Make It To 600 Miles, Repair Bill Estimated At $41k!

According to IAA, the repair costs for this damaged Supra are about $14k less than a brand new car.

Lamborghini Diablo VT-Based Zagato Raptor One-Off Could Spark A Bidding War

The Zagato Raptor Concept never reached production despite being much lighter and cooler than the Diablo VT.

Model X And Forester Engage In Highway “Battle” – But Is The Subaru Driver The Only One To Blame?

The driver of the Subaru seemed willing to ram a Tesla that didn’t give room for him to merge in his lane.

Production Audi E-Tron Sportback Teased, Will Be Joined In LA By RS Q8

The Audi e-tron Sportback will feature Digital Matrix headlights and the same powertrain as the e-tron.

One-Off Lamborghini Concept S Shows Up For Auction… Again

You’ll have to take a trip to Abu Dhabi on November 30 to bid on the Lamborghini Concept S.

2020 Skoda Octavia RS Rendered As The More Practical Golf GTI Mk8 Alternative

The new Skoda Octavia RS is expected to debut in 2020 with two body styles and two engines.

2020 Audi S8 Does 0-62 MPH In 3.8 Seconds, LWB Version Coming To America

The 563 HP 2020 Audi S8 is priced from $129,500 in the United States.

2020 Audi Q3 Sportback Is Trendier Than A Regular Q3, But Not Necessarily Better

The Audi Q3 Sportback reviewed here was the 45 TFSI version with a 227 HP 2.0-liter gasoline engine.