NTSB Report Suggests Tesla’s Autopilot System Could Be At Fault In Fatal Model X Crash

The National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) has released its preliminary report (PDF) on the fatal accident that involved a Tesla Model X in Autopilot mode.

While the report is still preliminary and subject to change, the NTSB says the accident occurred in Mountain View, California on March 23rd at approximately 9:27 am PDT. The 2017 Tesla Model X P100D was traveling south on US Highway 101 in a high-occupancy-vehicle lane.

According to data retrieved from the crossover, the 38-year-old driver was using the “advanced driver assistance features traffic-aware cruise control and autosteer lane-keeping assistance, which Tesla refers to as Autopilot.” As the Model X approved a “paved gore area” dividing the main lanes of US-101 from the SH-85 exit ramp, the crossover moved to the left and entered the gore area.

The Tesla continued traveling through the gore area until it struck a crash attenuator, which was mounted on the end of a concrete barrier, at a speed of approximately 71 mph (114 km/h). Following the collision, the Tesla rotated counterclockwise and the front portion of the vehicle separated from the rest of the Model X. The crossover was also involved in subsequent collisions with a 2017 Audi A4 and a 2010 Mazda 3.

What caused the accident remains the heart of the investigation and the NTSB says the Autopilot system was engaged on four separate occasions during the 32-minute trip including continuously during the final 19 minutes prior to the collision. During these final moments, the Model X provided two visual warnings and one auditory alert for the driver to place his hands on the steering wheel. In the final minute before the collision, hands were detected on the steering wheel for just 34 seconds. In the final six seconds, no hands were detected on the wheel.

While the driver wasn’t keeping his hands on the steering wheel, it appears the Autopilot system steered the crossover into the concrete barrier. As the NTSB notes, eight seconds prior to the crash the Tesla was following a lead vehicle and traveling at around 65 mph (104 km/h). One second later, the model “began a left steering movement” while still following the lead vehicle. Four seconds before the crash, the Model X stopped following the lead vehicle and this caused the crossover to speed up as the cruise control system was set at 75 mph (120 km/h). Three seconds before the crash, the Model X increased its speed from 62 mph (100 km/h) to 70.8 mph (114 km/h).

No braking or evasive steering movements were detected prior to the collision and the NTSB says the crash breached the Model X’s lithium-ion battery pack resulting in a fire. The driver was still belted in his seat but bystanders were able to remove him from the crossover before it was engulfed in flames. The driver later died at a local hospital.

The Mountain View Fire Department extinguished the fire and the Model X was eventually transported to an impound lot in San Mateo. While at the impound lot, the Tesla’s battery “emanated smoke and audible venting.” However, a thermal imaging camera showed it wasn’t actually on fire. Five days after the crash, the battery reignited and was extinguished by the San Mateo Fire Department.

Unfortunately, the crash attenuator on the concrete barrier was damaged by an accident involving a 2010 Toyota Prius on March 12th. The NTSB didn’t make much mention of this, but it’s possible the previous damage could have reduced the attenuator’s effectiveness.

more photos...
  • Spyder Hole Fantome

    I’m not surprised. Some are calling this system the Teslakaze Pilot.

  • Kyle Newberry

    Sad for the loss of life, but I’ll take it to keep real cars and drivers on the road!

  • Alfa Giulia QV

    Sure, the system did play a role in the crash but the real blame should be on the driver for their over reliance on it.

    • brn

      Not so much over reliance, but lack of attention. Per the report, the car repeatedly asked the driver to take control. Makes it easy to put most of the blame on the driver.

  • Can the driver hire the dream team lawyers to fight at the court?

  • TheHake

    A 38 yo professional (he had to be a professional to buy such an expensive car) should not be fooled by advertising like that. It is HIS OWN FAULT. However, I agree that Tesla should stop calling it Autopilot.

    • Jarosław Kotowicz

      No. She was just rich. That’s all.

  • Auf Wiedersehen

    All these accidents that result in fire get the same response from Musk and proponents. “ICE cars catch fire during accidents too.” But NOT 5 days later in an impound lot! Let’s call it what it is. A giant drive-able cell phone and we know what happens to these batteries when they are breached. I would like to see stats on ICE cars that result in fires on scene as opposed to Li-ion battery powered vehicles. Five days later is irrelevant stats as I think we know a gasoline engine will not spontaneously reignite 5 days later. Insane…

  • Perry F. Bruns

    Until battery designs change, we will have to look at fire containment areas for lithium-ion units involved in catastrophic collisions.

  • Vassilis

    The blame can be shared between the system and the driver but I don’t see Tesla admitting to that part of the blame. It’s just sad.

Most Expensive Mustang Ever? The $2.2 Million 1967 Shelby GT500 Super Snake

This makes the first production 2020 Super Snake, which sold for $1.1 million, look like a bargain.

Will Toyota Ever Launch A Convertible Supra To Combat The Z4?

According to chief engineer Tetsuya Tada, an open top Supra is something Toyota would consider .

One Brave Soul Decided To Acquire This Wrecked Corvette ZR1

This ZR1 is definitely beyond repair, yet someone stepped up to the challenge and became its new owner.

Could Genesis Be Working On A High-Performance G70 After All?

Will the BMW M3 and Mercedes-AMG C63 get a challenger from Korea? Well, stranger things have happened.

One-Of-One 2020 Toyota GR Supra Sells For Colossal $2.1 Million!

This 2020 Supra’s standout feature is the one-off, factory Phantom Grey matte paint.

New Kia Ceed Seems Like A Smart Choice In A Crowded Segment

Kia’s new compact hatch offers great value, good comfort and smart looks, but are they enough?.

2019 Skoda Superb Practically Undisguised As It Inches Closer To Debut

Steady but effective improvements are in the pipeline for Skoda’s range-topping model.

2019 Toyota Yaris Arrives In The UK With New Y20 And GR Sport Models

Toyota’s prolific supermini receives a boost in style and attitude, plus a limited version, for the new model year.

Cupra Ateca Is Very Fast And Well-Rounded, But It Lacks Character

As the first product of the newly founded performance brand it’s very good, yet not that exciting.

Here’s What It Costs To Maintain An Impressive 30-Vehicle Collection

Harry Metcalfe reveals just how expensive it was to own 16 cars and 14 motorcycles last year.