Tesla Model X Burnt To Ashes On Frozen Vermont Lake

Well, two burnt Teslas in the same week is rather unusual, even way back when the Model S still had its teething problems. But this is not what it might seem at first glance. Carscoop’s reader Scott Huntington has the story.

Nowadays, Elon Musk’s company has gone through the pains of becoming a mass manufacturer – so you can imagine my surprise when a news article crossed my feed that a Tesla Model X had burned to a crisp on a frozen lake, just minutes from my house. What happened to cause this supposedly super-safe Tesla to burn down to rubble?

The Model X is an SUV, but without some expensive upgrades, it’s not a car that you want to take off-road. That being said, it should handle some snow and ice, and the owner of this particular example took it to the frozen Lake Champlain to try to do some ice fishing. This isn’t uncommon, as oftentimes, cars and trucks come out here when the ice is thick enough. However, these are usually pickups or older cars, and almost always have a price tag well under the $80k+ that the Model X goes for.

A Rock, or Something Else?

According to the Shelburne Police Department, the owner hit a rock sometime during his trek to his favorite ice fishing spot. The car started making some odd noises after this impact, and shortly after caught fire. I walked out to investigate and quickly realized that the middle of a frozen lake is not a place where rocks typically hang out. However, I did see something that might have been the cause of the incident.

Between the shore and the pile of wreckage, there are several small concrete and metal posts that stick out of the water anywhere between 6 and 12 inches. These are used in the warmer months to tie up the boats, and unlike the floating docks that rise and fall with the water, these are permanent and can’t be moved.

Photo Scott Huntington/Carscoops.com

They were solidly frozen into the ice and could easily do some serious damage to the underside of any car that would drive over them. Some were easy to see, while others were hidden under the snow. It would not be out of the question for these to be what caused the fire.

You Don’t Want To Mess With Lithium

While Tesla has no comment on the matter, Popular Mechanics theorized that when the car struck the rock (or concrete pole), the impact damaged the car’s lithium-ion battery pack.

Lithium is currently the metal of choice when it comes to batteries, but when it is exposed to air, it is extremely volatile. As you can see in this clip from the YouTube channel The King of Random, the host, Nate is trying to remove the lithium from an AA battery, and just the act of unrolling the compacted lithium metal is enough to make it spontaneously ignite. It’s not hard to imagine that a punctured Tesla battery pack, which contains an estimated 63 kilograms (138 pounds) of lithium, would be capable of burning a Model X to the ground in no time at all.

Photo Scott Huntington/Carscoops.com

All that’s left on the ice is a burned-out husk, making it easy to see the car’s steel reinforced cabin. The fire didn’t melt the ice enough to drop the car into the water below, but it did soften the surface layers, so the husk of this Model X is securely stuck to the surface. When I went out this morning, workers there were busy chipping away at it, using salt to melt the areas where the car was most frozen. They had propane takes out to heat up the metal, but found the salt was more efficient.

It’s a job I wouldn’t want to have. They had been there four hours by the time arrived, and still had quite a bit of work to do. Plus, the sounds of the ice cracking in the changing temperatures was unnerving to say the least. It’s great that they’re getting the majority of it out, but there also comes a point where it gets a little too risky.

It should go without saying, but if you’re going to drive an $80,000 car out on the ice… watch where you’re going.

Scott Huntington is an automotive writer and blogger living in Vermont and covering everything from the Model T to the Model 3. Say hi on Twitter @SMHuntington or check out his site, Off The Throttle.


more photos...

Photos Scott Huntington/Carscoops.com

  • :/ Yurr

    Wow another fire from Tesla🙄

    • Stephen G

      FYI BMW recalled 1.6 million cars last year because of fires. In the first eight months of 2018 34 BMW burned. None of these incidents however was caused by a dumbass owner.

      • DanSemering

        My boss BMW caught fire in the parking lot !!! They didn’t know why,….He went back to a Toyota

  • TB

    I wouldn’t buy a Tesla even if someone else paid for it…at least for now anyways…too many fires…too many accidents…too many quality issues.

    • Dylan Wentworth

      I wouldn’t buy a Tesla even if someone else paid for it…at least for now anyways…too many fires…too many accidents…too many quality issues.

      You literally wouldn’t buy a tesla if someone else paid for it precisely because someone else bought it for you. Do you mean to say you wouldn’t accept it as a gift if someone else bought and paid for it?

      • TheAmerican2point0

        It’s obvious what he means though.
        And, If someone bought a Tesla and gave it to me, I’d say thanks and sell it right away and buy a real car

      • TB

        I would say that is correct…yes. That or turn right around and flip it.

        That said…if Tesla can resolve these issues down the road I would certainly reconsider…but not at this time…

        • Dylan Wentworth

          That’s better. 😉

  • Jason Miller

    Let’s be real here. Any electric car would have went up like that in the same scenario…

    • Jay

      To be fair any low car would have some pretty bad damage doing over something like that. Maybe not burning to the ground but it could be totaled from undercarriage damage as well.

  • Mr. EP9

    Seem weird that it caught fire in the middle of a frozen lake. Maybe something overheated or insurance fraud. The latter is probably unlikely but it’s still a possibility.

  • Richard Alexander

    Teslas are not ready for prime time. They are bought by 2 kinds of people: (1) people who made 8 figures because they work for a unicorn or (2) people trying to look like cool kids.

    • Jason Miller

      Puncture the battery pack on any electric car and it will do the same thing. Get real. Hell even a gas tank might burst into flames.

  • no25

    put it in rice.


  • Sovereignty

    Best Tesla ever.

    • Jay

      they have to watch out for them reigniting.

Hot Rods And Electric Motors Are A Match Made In Heaven

Although huge V8s used to be synonymous with the genre, the times, they are a changin.

Here’s What It’s Like To Own The Nissan Leaf For A Year

The long-term test reveals the ups and downs of actual Leaf ownership.

Next-Gen Kia Optima To Have A Progressive Design With A Strong Identity

The upcoming Optima probably will be more conservative than the new Hyundai Sonata.

Porsche Cayenne Coupe: Should You Cancel That Bimmer X6?

Was the Cayenne Coupe worth the wait? Yes, it was – and then some .

Check Out The Fun Exterior Colors Of The Hyundai Venue

Sales of the Hyundai Venue in the United States will commence later this year.

Can The Audi Q8 Make A Statement Among Other SUV Coupes?

If comfort is what tickles your fancy, then the Q8 is apparently the one to go for.

All-New Opel Corsa Gets Dressed In GSi Suit, Tries On An OPC Tux, Too

Apart from the usual versions, the brand new Corsa will also come in warm and hot hatch guise as well.

The Airbus Alpha Two Is The Company’s Flying Taxi Future

The Airbus Alpha Two has completed a number of test flights and hit 170 km/h.

Audi Considering An All-Electric A8, Decision Still Pending

What’s next? Electric BMW 7-Series and Mercedes-Benz S-Class? Quite possibly, yes.

What If The Aston Martin DB11’s Replacement Were An Edgy Shooting Brake?

The DB12, as we expect it will be named, will undoubtedly be a very high-tech product.