And Then There Were Three: BMW’s Finest Vie For The Crown Of Best M Car Ever

BMW’s M division has produced some of the finest sports cars the world has ever known, and for Autocar’s latest test, its editors decided to find out which is the best among them.

For the test, the publication put the E30 M3, E46-generation M3 CSL and new M2 Competition alongside each other.

There’s no doubt that these are three of the very best ever developed by the M Division, if we were organizing the test, we would have tried to also get an E92 M3 GTS and a 1M Coupe. Anyhow, if you can’t get ’em all, then you’ll have to make do with what you have.

Also Watch: One M3 To Rule Them All – Meet The Exquisite E30 Sport Evolution

The first car tested is E30 M3. It may not be the first M-branded road car built, but it is perhaps the most famous, even though just 16,202 examples were built. Powering comes from the company’s S14 naturally aspirated four-cylinder, with displacement ranging from 2.0-liters to 2.5-liters depending on the year (and market).

The journos then jumped into the E46 M3 CSL, whose production was capped at a mere 1,383 units. It is 243 lbs (110 kg) lighter than the standard model and the desirable S54 straight-six engine was modified to deliver more power and provide an even more intoxicating note.

Last, but in no way least, is the M2 Competition – and its inclusion might come as a surprise to some simply because it is so new. Powering the car is the same S55 twin-turbo inline-six as the previous-generation M3 and M4, which pumps out 405 HP and 406 lb-ft (550 Nm) of torque between 2350 rpm and 5230 rpm.

All of them are true masterpieces and any petrolhead would love to have them in their garage. Which one gets the nod, though?


  • Six_Tymes

    E46 All the way!!! you can keep the m2 with its joke canted drivers seat

  • Mill0048

    Yeah, that’s my order too. Except, that I like what I hear about the M2. Plus it tidy and looks nice.

    • Bash

      I totally understand what you sayin. I had a hard time making up my decision too. But I once owned and driven the iconic M3. I still think I was a bad decision to sell it.

      • Mill0048

        I’m jelly. I’ve never even driven any of the M3’s and that first gen probably would’ve resonated with me a lot. Simple rwd, performance car with usable power.

Watch A Pair Of Porsche 918 Spyders Give Much More Powerful Rivals A Good Lesson

Thanks to its hybrid powertrain and all-wheel drive, the 918 Spyder can hit 62 mph (100 km/h) in less than 2.5 seconds, scaring some serious machinery.

What Would You Call The BMW Concept 4’s Grille? Coffins? Waffle Iron? Beaver Teeth? Have Your Say

The grille of the BMW Concept 4 has caused a huge amount of controversy about its design – and for very good reason.

Tuned Mercedes-AMG GT 63 S With 818 HP Is Simply WOW!

Posaidon is also offering an 868 hp upgrade for all modern AMGs powered by its twin-turbo, 4.0-liter V8.

Moving House? The C7 Corvette Can Double As A Couch Transporter

Using a ‘Vette to move a large piece of furniture? Apparently, it can be done, though we would pick a vehicle more suited to the task.

Untitled And Unregistered Honda S2000 Could Be Yours For A Little Under $100,000

The same car sold for $70,000 earlier this year.

Tesla’s Nurburgring Attempt Could Be In Vain As Porsche Set The Lap Record With The Standard Taycan Turbo

Porsche didn’t use the more powerful Taycan Turbo S, so they could potentially beat Tesla in the end.

McLaren Thinks SUVs Aren’t Cool, Electrification Is – But Tech’s Still Not Up To Par

Even though tan SUV would boost its annual production from 6k units to 15k, Woking is convinced it’s not right for them.

Bentley Bentayga Stetson Edition Is An Ultra-Luxury Crossover For Cowboys

The special edition is available exclusively at a Texas dealership and features unique styling inside and out.

VW ID.4 Crossover To Be Unveiled In February

The model will be the production version of the ID Crozz concepts.

BMW’s Fall Updates Include A New Mild-Hybrid System For The 5-Series

Other updates include a carbon fiber roof for the 8-Series Gran Coupe and an M Performance package for the M135i xDrive.