The Grand Tour’s SUV Tests Reveals All Of The Pitfalls With Modern Crossovers

Cars are an extremely personal thing – everyone has their own set of favorites and likes their own group of automakers. But even enthusiasts can get together in their hatred for crossovers. And there’s a simple reason as to why – the body style serves no purpose.

For episode number 10 in season 2, “The Grand Tour” tested three high-performance crossovers. Jeremy Clarkson was behind the wheel of an Alfa Romeo Stelvio Quadrifoglio, Richard Hammond brought a Porsche Macan Turbo Performance Pack to the party, and James May drove the Range Rover Velar.

We’re sure you’ve all watched the episode by now, but if you haven’t or if you need a refresher, check it out again before I start bashing the machines.

The trio of vehicles actually cover the range of available crossovers in the segment well. The Stelvio Quadrifoglio is the most raucous of the bunch, Macan Turbo Performance Pack is the best all-rounder, and Velar is the best looking, which is a major selling point for crossovers.

If I remove my salty enthusiast glasses for a moment, it’s easy to see why American consumers are flocking to crossovers and SUVs in hordes. The vehicles are high off the ground, have a spacious cargo area, and have words like all-wheel drive and all-terrain somewhere in the monroney. All of these things are important when it snows a few inches in winter and when the time comes for the biweekly Costco run.

But if that’s all it takes, what’s wrong with a sedan? Or God forbid, a wagon? They even have ones that are built to handle some dirt. So why are crossovers such a hit? Even when I take a step back and try to understand the situation, I still don’t get it. And after watching “The Grand Tour’s” episode, I think the trio were trying to show just how idiotic the SUV and crossover craze really is.

The episode starts with the crew heading to Canada and attempting to beat or get as close to a lap time that was set by a BMW M3 CS sedan, an actual-to-goodness sports car. The sporty M3 managed to lap the track in 2:22, which none of the crossover’s managed to get close to. The Alfa was the quickest crossover of the bunch and managed to set a time of 2:40, which is 18 seconds off the pace of the BMW.

The Grand Tour SUV Test

And it wasn’t just the lap times that were off, all of the presenters pointed out flaws in the vehicles’ designs that made them tiresome to drive on a track. I know a lot of you are probably saying something a long the lines of, “The Stelvio Quadrifoglio may have 505 hp, but it’s not a track machine.”

Fine, its SUV bodystyle should be good at holding large cargo though, right? The crew then set off to try to fit dogs into the back of the crossovers. And before anyone claims that no one puts dogs into the back of a SUV, my parents used to do it with two Saint Bernards, which were massive dogs, and it all worked out.

Unfortunately, none of the dogs were very happy in the back of the SUV and the moronic electric tailgates meant that the doors couldn’t be closed. So if you’re planning to go to Ikea or Home Depot, these cars aren’t going to be very helpful.

Still, I can overlook all of this stuff, because chances are, if you’re wealthy enough to purchase one of these vehicles, you’re probably going to get furniture or large items delivered to you. So, I can overlook these downsides. The majority of realistic owners won’t be showing up to track days trying to set blistering lap times. What they will be doing, though, is possibly traversing over rough terrain and driving in inclement weather.

The next two tests were to see how the crossovers dealt with interesting terrain. The trio set off to beat a horse around a dirt arena in a barrel racing test. Incredibly, the Macan Turbo Performance Package and Stelvio Quadrifoglio’s all-wheel-drive systems freaked out. Both crossovers entered into “limp-home” mode. The Velar managed to survive the test, but took twice as long as the horse to finish the course.

The Grand Tour SUV Test

The last test saw the presenters attempt to cross over rough terrain while towing a boat. These crossovers aren’t meant for towing and aren’t meant for being rugged off-roaders. Hilariously, Clarkson ditches the Alfa and goes with a Ford F-150 Raptor for the test and reveals just how worthless the other crossovers are.

Watching Hammond attempt to get up a hill was painful, as the Porsche looked like it was fish out of water. The Velar didn’t have as hard of a time, but boy the F-150 Raptor just embarrassed the others. The entire episode revealed that crossovers are useless. They’re not as good as a sedan on the track, not as good as a minivan when it comes to holding cargo, and not as good as a pickup when it comes to off-roading.

Hopefully, non-enthusiasts watched the episode and saw how ridiculous crossovers really are. So what can they do? If you’re need of a vehicle that can hold numerous dogs and can go off-roading, get a proper SUV. A Toyota Land Cruiser, Land Rover Ranger Rover, Toyota 4Runner, Jeep Wrangler, or Jeep Grand Cherokee are all great options that can do a better job than a regular crossover.

None of these options, though, will be good on a track. But there’s a solution for that, as well. Go on Craigslist or eBay and find a cheap Mazda MX-5 Miata. That little sports car will be funnier than any crossover on a track and won’t break the bank like one of the useless machines will either.

I understand why minivans exist, I even get why the Ford Expedition and Lincoln Navigator are cash cows for the brands, but I will never understand why crossovers are popular. And it looks like the trio from “The Grand Tour” share my same rationale.

more photos...
  • Auto

    After seeing a Velar in real life yesterday, I have to say it looks like it was stretched or exaggerated.

  • scjeff

    So by inference what this article is saying is if you don’t go to the track, don’t need the room of a minivan, and don’t go offroad crossovers are good? I know that’s not the gist of the article but it’s a strange way to prove how bad a type of car is by pointing out all the things it can’t do when the vast majority of crossover buyers don’t care or do those activities.

    • LeStori

      Well I enjoy watching SUVs rolling over at the hint of an accident. Roll, Roll, Roll they go. Should be called RRRs.

  • LeStori

    The SUV is the Compromise Candidate. Does nothing well but does a little bit of all. The Mum’s “car”.

    • Sébastien

      well it does SELL well 🙂

  • roy

    The high riding position of the drivers compared to the normal car is the biggest selling point

    • Obsequious Lickspittle

      If only the motor industry could produce a cheap economical crane they’d be on to a winner.

      • roy

        True

      • TheHake

        Not everyone likes the low slung driving position of cars.

        • Obsequious Lickspittle

          Oh, i agree. It feels like the default now though from manufacturers. And to those who do like such a vehicle, can they stop braking at every corner when I am behind them?

          • TheHake

            Bwahahaha. Now that’s just FUNNY!

  • YUDHA BAGASKARA

    what was actually happened to stelvio? stolen or cannot be towed?

    • AxlRock

      They needed to tow a trailer with a boat on it for the last challenge, the Stelvio couldn’t so Clarkson ditched it

  • AxlRock

    How many people close their electric tailgates manually?

    • Enter Ranting

      Nothing says rugged outdoorsman like an electrically-operated tailgate.

  • Miknik

    In fairness though, the M3 was driven in more professional manner, probably accounting for most of the difference. After all, this is entertainment and not a scientific assessment

  • mkole1964

    Second paragraph from the end. Funnier? Really?

  • Rocket

    “The entire episode revealed that crossovers are useless. They’re not as good as a sedan on the track, not as good as a minivan when it comes to holding cargo, and not as good as a pickup when it comes to off-roading.”

    Useless is a ridiculous exaggeration. Crossovers are like a Leatherman … They’re not ideal for any one task, but they’re a good compromise when you need your daily driver to do more than one thing. You know … like almost everybody on the face of the planet.

    So go ahead and buy a screwdriver if you do nothing but remove screws, but you’re going to be shit out of luck if you encounter a bolt.

  • DMJ

    This segment from Grand Tour hits some soft spots from SUV’s, but this article is ridiculous and not even funny. Grand Tour is a car show and a humor show, everyone knows that 525 liters of trunk space (Alfa) is more than enough for a dog. For european standards, it’s actually a huge trunk. Everyone knows that a Stelvio QV or a Macan Turbo aren’t made for rock climbing like a Defender or a Wrangler. And that a AWD SUV will never be better in a track than a RWD hardcore sedan like a BMW M3 CS. I’m not a fanboy of SUVs, but there are limits to biased perpectives.

  • Honda NSX-R

    If only there were more wagons and hatchbacks to choose from (especially here in America)

  • Honda NSX-R

    “If you’re need of a vehicle that can hold numerous dogs and can go off-roading, get a proper SUV. A Toyota Land Cruiser, Land Rover Ranger Rover, Toyota 4Runner, Jeep Wrangler, or Jeep Grand Cherokee are all great options that can do a better job than a regular crossover.”

    The Jeep Grand Cherokee is a crossover, just saying 😛

    • TheHake

      Nooooooo. Grand Cherokee is a proper off-roader. Ditch the road-biased tyres and you have a very capable off-roader.

  • TheHake

    Since I’ve NEVER been on a track with my car, a sedan is useless to me… My dogs are all Scotties, so I don’t need a van. In Europe you’re not allowed to do offroading so pickups are useless. But I do like a raised seating position, getting in and out easily, having extra space… So no, for me (and LOTS of other people) SUV’s ARE NOT useless.

How Does The All-New Audi RS 6 Avant Compare To Its Predecessor?

The 2020 Audi RS6 Avant even promises to be a better driver’s car than the previous-generation model.

The Porsche 988 Vision Is The Next Mid-Engined Hypercar We Need From Stuttgart

A mid-engine Porsche rival to the McLaren 720S would do the world a lot of good.

2020 Honda Civic Si Charges $735 More For Subtle Styling Tweaks, Added Kit

2020 Honda Civic Si Coupe and Sedan gain similar styling updates to the regular Civic and more safety tech.

Hyundai RM19 Mid-Engine Sports Car Hiding Under Veloster N TCR Bodywork

The RM19 previews Hyundai N’s performance halo car that will feature a mid-engine, rear-wheel-drive layout.

2020 Fiat Cronos HGT Is South America’s Economy Sedan With A Sporty Twist

Inspired by the Argo HGT, the Fiat Cronos HGT trim level brings exclusive sporty design tweaks and more equipment.

Next-Generation Hyundai Tucson To Have A Santa Fe-Inspired Face

The next-generation Hyundai Tucson will be sold with a range of new powertrains.

Car Vending Machine Trialed In London With Renault Zoe Inside

The bespoke contactless car vending machine allows purchases of up to £21,000.

Porsche Invests In Short-Wave Infrared Sensor Technology

Porsche has purchased a minority stake in Israeli start-up company TriEye.

Land Rover Discovery Mobile Malaria Lab Completes Mission

This SVO-kitted Land Rover Discovery covered 4,567 miles across Namibia, Zambia, Tanzania and Kenya.

Porsche Cayenne Turbo S E-Hybrid Laps Unfinished Gotland Ring

The 670 HP Porsche Cayenne Turbo S E-Hybrid lapped the unfinished Gotland Ring in 3:51 minutes.