Audi R8 vs BMW i8 vs McLaren 570S vs Mercedes-AMG GT C In Topless Sports Car Feud

If you ever wondered which topless sports car is the fastest, Carwow has brought the Audi R8 V10 Spyder, BMW i8 Roadster, McLaren 570S Spider and Mercedes-AMG GT C Roadster together for one of their classic drag races.

Drop-top sports cars tend to be more exciting than their fixed-roof counterparts, simply because they allow you to get exposed to the elements. Having no roof means that their impressive powertrains can flood the cabin more easily with the right kind of noise, therefore making them more enjoyable even if you’re not driving on a race track.

Each of the four contenders takes a different approach for the same goal; the R8 Spyder features a naturally aspirated V10 with 540hp and 398lb-ft strapped to the company’s Quattro all-wheel drive system.

The 570S Spider is powered by a twin-turbo 3.8-liter V8 with 562hp and 442lb-ft of torque that are sent to the rear wheels only. The i8 Roadster takes a whole different approach to the concept of a sports car, featuring a plug-in hybrid powertrain with a small 1.5-liter three cylinder petrol unit sitting at its heart. The BMW’s combined output is just 368hp, but it has all-wheel drive and lots of zero-rpm torque from its electric motors.

Finally we have the GT C Roadster. The group’s only front-engine car is powered by AMG’s twin-turbo 4.0-liter V8, which makes 547hp and 502lb-ft of torque. With all this power sent to the rear only, this could prove to be the trickiest of the three off the line.

Now that we’ve laid out the specs, it’s time to find out how those four fared in the drag race.


  • Bo Hanan

    BMW should not be in this test.

    • Matteo Tommasi

      Ferrari Portofino instead

  • SteersUright

    McLaren is epically fast and epically ugly. The R8 looks ok, if a bit dated, but my god that V10 should just be recorded and pumped into the speakers of every other sports car in existence. The MB neither sounds nor looks great, but it is still decently impressive in the real world. The i8 was never my cup of tea. An almost-super car with skinny wheels and plasticky kids toy appearance to it, it looks just cool enough but never wows.

    • TheAmerican

      Yeah I hate how people call it a supercar just because it looks sporty. It has 369 horsepower and those skinny wheels.

  • Bash

    This is great. It’s great to see those drag races without a Tesla or someone mentioning a Tesla.


The First 2019 Ford GT Heritage Edition Sold For $2.5 Million

All proceeds from the sale of the first 2019 Ford GT Heritage Edition went to charity.

2020 Cadillac XT5 Facelift Leaked In China, Previews American Model

The XT5 gets minor styling updates and a new turbo four that might make it Stateside.

Rolls-Royce Reviews Its Most Spectacular Bespoke Models Of 2018

Here are the finest cars Rolls-Royce built last year for its most fastidious customers.

Staggering Barn-Find Discovery With Over 80 Legendary And Classic Cars

A massive collection of 81 barn-find classic cars was auctioned in France.

This Life-Sized 2019 Silverado LEGO Truck Took Over 2,000 Hours And 334,000 Bricks To Build

The LEGO Silverado is a full-size replica of the all-new 2019 Trail Boss.

VW Considers Extending €9,000 Diesel Incentives In Germany

Automakers are under heavy pressure to avert diesel bans in key German cities.

Ford Now Betting Big On Level 3 Autonomous Systems

Ford had previously stated that it would mostly bypass Level 3 autonomy and focus on Level 4 development.

Toyota UK Overbooked Supra A90 Edition Orders As Massive Demand Caused Technical Failure

Affected customers will get a free two-year service plan for their regular Supra.

Mercedes-Benz Seriously Considers Building Passenger Cars In Egypt

Mercedes would also support local authorities in other projects by offering their expertise in different fields.

Vuhl 05RR Street Legal Track Car Has Veyron-Beating Power-To-Weight Ratio

The 385hp Mexican-built supercar is now on sale in the U.S. and Europe.