FCA Wins A Round Against Mahindra, But Indians Bullishly Bringing Jeep Clone To Detroit Show

The legal battle between Fiat Chrysler Automobiles and Mahindra is far from over, but the Auburn Hills-based automaker has scored a victory against Mahindra and its Jeep-like Roxor.

In an initial determination, the United States International Trade Commission found that FCA is “not contractually barred from enforcing its intellectual property” rights against Mahindra.

In a 20 page document which laid out the case, the commission revealed the fight between the two companies has been going on since FCA’s predecessor, Chrysler Group LLC, learned Mahindra was preparing to introduce the Scorpio in the United States in 2008. Upon learning this, Chrysler reached out to Mahindra as they believed the Scorpio’s grille was “confusingly similar to a Jeep brand vehicle grille.” Chrysler requested that Mahindra change the grille on the Scorpio and the two companies eventually came to an agreement on an “approved grille design” after Chrysler initially rejected two other design proposals.

According to the 2009 agreement, Chrysler promised it wouldn’t go after Mahindra for any “claim for infringement of Chrysler’s trade dress, trademark, or other intellectual property rights in the United States” as long as the company stuck with the approved grille design. Despite this, Mahindra never launched the Scorpio in the United States.

While the Scorpio was a no-show, Mahindra launched the Roxor last year. FCA objected to this as the SUV had an “overall exterior appearance” similar to the Jeep CJ and Wrangler. The company also took issue with the model’s Jeep-like grille which wasn’t the same as the approved grille design from 2009.

The issue was eventually brought up with the United States International Trade Commission and they determined that the 2009 agreement, which featured an image of the approved grille design, removed “any ambiguity about the specific grille design that Chrysler permitted Mahindra to use.” The commission also noted the agreement did “not contain any language allowing for variations on the grille design.”

Mahindra attempted to get around this, but the commission said their arguments were “not persuasive because there is no textual indication in the 2009 agreement that might have permitted adaptations of the pictured grille design.” They went on to say the meaning of the original agreement was “clear and unambiguous.”

As a result, the commission found the Roxor grille has a different shape, different proportions and different design details than the approved grille design from 2009. The designer of the Roxor’s grille also testified that the “perimeter, aspect ratio, slot aspect ratio, logo proportion, and finish are all different” than what was approved nearly a decade ago.

In a short statement, the automaker told us “FCA US is pleased that the Administrative Law Judge agreed that there is no merit to Mahindra’s position in this matter. We look forward to moving to the next stage of the case and showing that the Roxor infringes on the iconic trade dress and trademarks of the Jeep brand.”

While the United States International Trade Commission handed a win to FCA, the Roxor isn’t going away anytime soon. The Detroit Free Press reports the model will be shown at the North American International Auto Show next week and Mahindra has managed to sell approximately 3,000 Roxors in the United States and Canada so far.

  • lagunas3ca

    Frauds bringing cheap, Indian trash to Detroit show.

    • mihsf

      Jeep or whatever whichever company which owned Jeep at the time gave a licence to Mahindra. You can’t change your mind like this. Mahindra has the right to make it.

      • lagunas3ca

        Change my mind on how I feel about Mahindra duping hundreds of US auto dealers (friends) and walking away with more than $70 million in cash and trade secrets? Nothing but fraud, misrepresentation and conspiracy.

        • mihsf

          Nobody forced Jeep to give a licence to Mahindra. Had they not, Mahindra would not have built this vehicle.

          • lagunas3ca

            You lost me after misspelling license.

          • mihsf

            Just like nobody learnt you proper English AND nobody learnt you Americans aren’t the world.

      • brn

        There was an agreement. Mahindra went beyond that agreement. Jeep (FCA, whatever) was perfectly within their right to call foul.

    • Dude

      It’s designed and built in the US. And it’s not even a road car. If you don’t even have your facts straight you might be the trash…

      • lagunas3ca

        There’s a reason why it’s not a road car, and that’s because in the US we have this thing called regulations.

        • Dude

          That is not at all why. It’s not trying to be a road car. It’s the size of a UTV like a Polaris Ranger. Because that’s what it is. And I don’t know if we’ll ever have Indian cars, but that’s not relevant, I don’t really care, and that’s not what’s happening here.

          • lagunas3ca

            Dude, chill…
            Did I say it wasn’t designed in the US?
            Did I say it wasn’t built in the US?
            Did I say it’s a road car?
            Did I say it’s trying to be a road car?

          • Dude

            >Did I say it wasn’t designed in the US?
            >Did I say it wasn’t built in the US?
            -“bringing cheap Indian trash”
            I thought you were saying that it was an Indian import so I was wrong there but

            >Did I say it’s a road car?
            >Did I say it’s trying to be a road car?
            -“There’s a reason why it’s not a road car, and that’s because in the US…”
            Implies that it would be a road car otherwise. It wouldn’t be.

  • Thunderbolt

    3000 units sold in North America at $15,499 a piece (not including tax and fees), and for ATV purpose only, no way jose, I’d be better off getting at least 3 very used land cruisers for that price.

  • mihsf

    FCA is French? I didn’t know France had a third car manufacturer.
    It’s Italian/Dutch.

  • Dude

    FCA is the Italian/American corporation headquartered in the Netherlands and made by a merger of Fiat and Chrysler. Are you thinking of PSA?

    • Da Only Skid

      Dude, duuudde, you’re right my bad. It applies to either one. Thank you for pointing out the errs in my statement.

  • Bae Young

    They’ve never seen a BAIC BJ40

  • Bae Young

    PSA is French, FCA is Fiat Chrysler, the most reliable motor company that mankind have created.

  • Bae Young

    Mahindra itself is TOTAL crap by all means, its 1950s tech just don’t fit 21st century. However they could just sell re-badged Ssangyong at lower price, like Skoda to Volkswagen, but that is also depend on the market situation of Ssangyong, as Ssangyong is already a bottom brand and struggle to survive.

    • Human Being

      By no means is Mahindra’s tech crap. Roxor is supposed to be a bare-bones vehicle. Some of Mahindra’s vehicles such as the XUV500, Marazzo, etc are actually pretty good and competitive. Moreover, SsangYoung has improved only after its takeover by Mahindra, after which they came up with the Tivoli. Also, Mahindra also has done some tremendous innovation such as autonomous tractors, anti-collision system for junctions and Infrastructure to Vehicle communication protocol to name a few.

      • Bae Young

        It’s a Cart powered by a motorcycle engine. Ssangyong is a failed German-Korean company, even worse than Daewoo (SK GM now).

  • Wandering_Spirit

    Technologically a Lada minus the originality of the Lada Niva. Basically crap. I’d get a Lada. I’d never ge a Mahindra.

  • 🇦🇺Marshall

    Who knows, maybe the automotive world will get lucky and these two trash merchants will sink each other.

All-New Land Rover Defender Launching In September, Deliveries Start In Early 2020

Land Rover hasn’t decided whether it will launch the new Defender in Frankfurt or at a standalone event.

Woman Takes Truck In For Service, Sees It At Store And Decides To ‘Steal’ It Back

Following a viral Facebook post, the dealership fired the employee responsible for using the truck to run errands.

Audi Rumored To Be Working On High-Performance E-Tron GTR, Could Replace The R8

The rumored Audi e-tron GTR sounds a lot like last year’s PB18 e-tron concept.

2020 Dodge Charger Widebody Spied Undisguised During Promo Shoot

Recently previewed by a concept, the Charger Widebody is expected to be offered with two different V8 engines.

Toyota To Introduce 12 New Or Redesigned Models, Tundra Could Be Among Them

Besides the Tundra, we can expect a redesigned Sienna and possibly an all-new crossover.

All-New Buick Encore GX Compact Crossover Coming To The U.S.

In contrast, the new Encore subcompact SUV will not make it Stateside and the existing model will soldier on.

Jeep’s M-715 Five-Quarter Concept Has Hellcat Power, Carbon Bodywork

This Jeep pickup is based on an original 1968 M-715, although almost everything has been customized .

New Tesla Roadster Accelerates As Fast As One Of Musk’s Rockets

The Tesla Roadster will hit 60 mph in less than 2 seconds when it launches next year.

What Makes The Acura NSX’s $6,000 ‘Andaro’ Paint So Special?

Acura charges NSX buyers a cool $6,000 for its special Andaro paint option.

The Nissan Skyline R32 GT-R Makes Supra Values Look Even Sillier

You simply can’t deny the iconic status of an old Nissan Skyline GT-R, can you?.