AAA Says Android Auto And Apple CarPlay Are Less Distracting Than Traditional Infotainment Systems

Vehicles are quickly becoming high-tech toys on wheels and some automakers still haven’t perfected their infotainment systems.

While some systems are better than others, the AAA Foundation for Traffic Safety has released a new study which claims Android Auto and Apple CarPlay are less distracting than infotainment systems created by automakers.

While this seems subjective at first glance, the organization says performing complex tasks with Android Auto and Apple CarPlay were quicker than using traditional infotainment systems. AAA notes these systems can make a phone call 24 percent (5 seconds) faster than native infotainment systems and users can program the navigation system 31 percent (15 seconds) quicker.

A few seconds doesn’t sound like much but it can make the difference between life and death. As AAA explains, “drivers who take their eyes off the road for more than two seconds double their risk of a crash.” The group went on to note that distracted driving is responsible for more than 390,000 injuries and 3,500 deaths every year in the United States.

 

 

As part of the study, AAA teamed up with researchers from the University of Utah to evaluate five vehicles including the Honda Ridgeline, Ford Mustang, Chevrolet Silverado, Kia Optima and Ram 1500. They then tested the various infotainment systems against Android Auto with LG K7 and Google Pixel 2 smartphones as well as Apple CarPlay with an iPhone 7.

Overall, the results weren’t good for manufacture systems as their overall demand on users was rated “Very High.” In comparison, both Android Auto and Apple CarPlay had “Moderate” levels of demand.

AAA says Android Auto and Apple CarPlay “decrease the demand placed on drivers compared to similar technologies offered by automakers.” However, they cautioned both still create potentially unsafe levels of distraction and complex tasks shouldn’t be attempted while driving.

more photos...
  • annon

    Bullshit…any modern day navigation is distracting & takes focus off driving, no matter what the input is

    • Status

      While you’re at it, you might as well put the radio/entertainment and HVAC controls in there as they also distract and take away a drivers focus.

  • eb110americana

    Not surprising, considering people have had a lot more practice with iOS and Android outside of their vehicles. That, and manufacturer systems are largely hit-or-miss as far as intuitive use.

  • Bash

    I tried both, I find them equally distracting.

  • Matthew Boyd

    My car has it, it’s easier and quicker so that equates to less distracting. Any infotainment device is distracting though.

  • Marty

    To me it would be more interesting to benchmark against physical controls for climate and media playback. I want to know if we are going down the wrong track with touchscreens.

“I Eat Ass Decal” Lands Man In Jail, But He Might Get The Last Laugh

Following the arrest, officials decided not to prosecute the case over First Amendment concerns.

2019 Mercedes C-Class Is Still A First-Class Premium Cruiser

If it’s comfort you’re looking for, the revamped C-Class is still your best choice in the segment.

Volkswagen T-Cross Manages To Make A Very Good Case For Itself

The T-Cross can be flashy if that’s what the buyer wants, but it can also look very civilized.

New Suzuki Jimny Is Aimed At 4×4 Enthusiasts, But How Does It Go On Tarmac?

Its USP might be its unique off-roading abilities, yet the new Jimny doesn’t do that bad on tarmac, either.

Brown Sugar: This Audi A6 Sedan Is Oh So Sweetly Specced

Whoever ordered this A6 did a thorough search through the Audi Exclusive color palette.

Citroen Golden Scarab Recreates 120-Year-Old Automotive Legend

The Scarabee d’Or was the first car to have crossed the Sahara Desert, and his is a brand-new replica.

Co-Driver Makes A Total Mess Of Navigating In Rally Stage

The driver of this Mazda MX-5 was left a little dumbfounded by his navigator’s pace notes…

Wide-Body Chevy Camaro SS On Custom Wheels Is A Drama Queen

It might not be to everyone’s taste, but this tuned Camaro SS is a head-turning car.

Mazda Says 76 Per Cent Of Miata Buyers Opt For Stick Shifts

The MX-5 soft top is more frequently optioned with the manual than the RF targa.

The Grand National Is A Buick With Some Real Desirability

The Buick Grand National sports a 300 HP, 3.8-liter turbocharged V6 .