IIHS Says Today’s Driver Assistance Systems Aren’t Clever Enough

Today’s driver assistance systems can accelerate, brake and even steer for you in certain situations. However, according to the Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS), they’re still not advanced enough to substitute for human drivers completely.

While testing Level 2 self-driving technologies from Tesla, Mercedes, BMW and Volvo on the road as well as the track, the IIHS concluded that each system also came with potentially dangerous weaknesses, as reported by Automotive News.

“We don’t think any of these five systems can be relied on,” said IIHS chief research officer, David Zuby. “Drivers must remain attentive when these systems are in use.”

During four track-based tests, the IIHS discovered weaknesses in Volvo’s adaptive cruise control system, as well as Tesla’s automated emergency braking system, relative to competitors from Mercedes and BMW.

Meanwhile, on-road tests uncovered issues with all the systems, as every vehicle tested (except the Tesla Model 3) failed to respond to stationary vehicles ahead at one point or another. As for the Model 3, it displayed overly cautious braking 12 times during 180 miles (289 km) of testing – engineers reported that seven of its incidents coincided with tree shadows on the road.

“It’s not clear that the unnecessary braking is the direct trade-off associated with better detection of stopped lead vehicles, but it could be,” added Zuby. “We would need to do additional testing to understand that further.”

The IIHS also found issues of inconsistency with lane-keeping systems. Tesla’s Autosteer system did however manage to impress most in a series of six trials on three sections of curved road, where the Model 3 managed to stay inside the lane markings in all 18 attempts (the Model S crossed the lane line only once). Mercedes and Volvo’s active lane-keeping systems stayed inside the lane lines in just nine of 17 attempts, while BMW’s was successful in just 3 of 16 attempts.

The same test was then moved to a section of road with an incline so as to test the system’s ability to navigate hills. Here, the Model 3 stayed in its lane in all but one attempt, whereas the Mercedes system did well in 15 of 18 tries. Volvo performed positively in 9 of 16 attempts, the Tesla Model S in 5 of 18 and BMW shockingly failed all 14 attempts.

Another thing worth noting is that despite fairing well in some tests, the Model S and Model 3 had the most dramatic failures during track-based testing as both models hit stationary objects while engineers tested their automated emergency braking performance.

The IIHS is currently developing a comprehensive test scheme for these systems, which should be ready in about 12 months time, stated Zuby.

more photos...
  • vas

    Have bought a Seat Ateca 1.4 DSG 5 months ago and added all aforementioned driver assistance systems. Initially, took me some time to figure out what they are and do, and how they work. After having driven 11’000kms in Switzerland, Germany, Italy and Greece, have to admit that am very much impressed with these systems and how accurate they are!! ACC, lane assist and traffic jam assist just function optimally, had only 2 times emergency braking, both to cyclists in front of me that probably where still in the “view” area of the front camera while me trying to overtake them.
    Would not substitute them completely of course, but sure help you out in a long ride and in traffic situations 🙂

  • Earl Scheib

    I feel bad for those that had to wait for the IIHS to make statement.

  • TheBelltower

    I’m more concerned with the IIHS being “clever enough.” How about instead of simply observing the evolution of these systems, actually establishing minimum standards? These systems have been around for years, so I’m not real clear as to why they are just getting around to developing testing “schemes” that will take another year to roll out.


  • botornot387

    In other news, the sky is blue…

Hot Rods And Electric Motors Are A Match Made In Heaven

Although huge V8s used to be synonymous with the genre, the times, they are a changin.

Here’s What It’s Like To Own The Nissan Leaf For A Year

The long-term test reveals the ups and downs of actual Leaf ownership.

Next-Gen Kia Optima To Have A Progressive Design With A Strong Identity

The upcoming Optima probably will be more conservative than the new Hyundai Sonata.

Porsche Cayenne Coupe: Should You Cancel That Bimmer X6?

Was the Cayenne Coupe worth the wait? Yes, it was – and then some .

Check Out The Fun Exterior Colors Of The Hyundai Venue

Sales of the Hyundai Venue in the United States will commence later this year.

Can The Audi Q8 Make A Statement Among Other SUV Coupes?

If comfort is what tickles your fancy, then the Q8 is apparently the one to go for.

All-New Opel Corsa Gets Dressed In GSi Suit, Tries On An OPC Tux, Too

Apart from the usual versions, the brand new Corsa will also come in warm and hot hatch guise as well.

The Airbus Alpha Two Is The Company’s Flying Taxi Future

The Airbus Alpha Two has completed a number of test flights and hit 170 km/h.

Audi Considering An All-Electric A8, Decision Still Pending

What’s next? Electric BMW 7-Series and Mercedes-Benz S-Class? Quite possibly, yes.

What If The Aston Martin DB11’s Replacement Were An Edgy Shooting Brake?

The DB12, as we expect it will be named, will undoubtedly be a very high-tech product.