Consumer Reports Reveals Best Used Cars For Under $20K

Consumer Reports recently revealed the best automotive brands and models for 2018 but buyers with limited budgets don’t have to spend big to get a reliable car.

After complaining test data and hundreds of thousands of survey responses, the publication came up with the best used car picks for shoppers with a budget of $20,000 or less. The vehicles are from the 2008-2017 model years and have “much-better-than-average reliability.”

The small car category was dominated by imports including the Honda Fit, Kia Soul and Mazda3. Other good options include the Scion xB, Toyota Corolla and Toyota Prius. The only domestic car to make the cut was the Pontiac Vibe which is essentially a badge-engineered Toyota Matrix which also made the list.

Shoppers looking for a midsize sedan only have a few recommended choices such as the Honda Accord and Mazda6. Two Toyota models also made the list and they are the Avalon and Camry.

Buyers looking for a cut-rate luxury car are advised to check out the Acura TL and TSX as well as the Infiniti G and M sedans. On the Lexus side, there are four recommended models including the CT, ES, GS and LS. The only German car to make the cut was the 2010-2011 Mercedes E-Class.

Wagons and sports cars might not have much in common but the recommended choices come from Subaru, Scion and Toyota. On the sports car side, there’s the Subaru BRZ and Scion FR-S. Likewise, the best wagons are the Toyota Prius V and Venza.

The recommended list of crossovers and SUVs all come from Japanese automakers. They include the Acura RDX, Honda CR-V, Lexus RX and Mazda CX-5. Toyota also took four spots thanks to the 4Runner, Highlander, RAV4 and Sequoia.

While the truck market is dominated by Ford and General Motors, neither of their pickups made the recommended list. Instead, the publication steers people to the Honda Ridgeline and Toyota Tundra.

You can see which specific model years are recommended by Consumer Reports after the jump.

VIDEO

 

Consumer Reports’ Recommended Used Car Models

 

Small Cars

Honda Fit ’09-13
Kia Soul ’10-16
Mazda3 ’09-17
Pontiac Vibe ’08-10
Scion xB ’08-12, ’15
Toyota Corolla ’08-17
Toyota Matrix ’08-10
Toyota Prius ’08-15

Midsized & Large Cars

Honda Accord ’08-15
Mazda6 ’09-15
Toyota Avalon ’08-13
Toyota Camry ’08-15

Luxury Cars

Acura TL ’08-10, ’13
Acura TSX ’08-14
Infiniti G ’08-11, ’13
Infiniti M ’08, ’11
Lexus CT 200h ’11-13
Lexus ES ’08-12
Lexus GS ’08, ’10-11
Lexus LS ’08
Mercedes-Benz E-Class ’10-11

Sports Car

Scion FR-S ’14-15
Subaru BRZ ’14

Wagons

Toyota Prius V ’12-14
Toyota Venza ’09-12

SUVs

Acura RDX ’09-10, ’12
Honda CR-V ’08-14
Lexus RX ’08-10
Mazda CX-5 ’13-15
Toyota 4Runner ’08-09
Toyota Highlander ’08-10
Toyota RAV4 ’08-13
Toyota Sequoia ’08

Pickup Trucks

Honda Ridgeline ’08-10
Toyota Tundra ’08

  • John

    more like best japanese car under $20k
    how did that Pontiac Vibe made it there.. lol

    • SgtBeavis

      Because it’s a rebadged Toyota.

  • eye.surgeon

    Wow. Completely import cars except a Pontiac that doesn’t exist any more. Sad.

  • brn

    On average, domestic vehicles have a lower resale value. This makes them better used buys. CR didn’t seem to take this into account.

    In general, declaring “best buys” on used cars is a pretty tricky topic. Such lists should be avoided.

  • Nick099

    I have been following CR and their reports for a long time.

    I have bought cars that they claimed were “worse than average” expected reliability…and they returned much, much better than expected reliability.

    The point? I am not so sure they are so correct in their conclusions.

  • dumblikeyou2

    The red-headed stepchild isn’t the Pontiac Vibe, it’s the Mercedes E-class. Good luck with that one……

  • dumblikeyou2

    For a Mazda CX-5, I guess

  • Toronado_II

    Reliable but so boring overall !

Lamborghini Huracan Performante Crashes While Leaving Car Meet

This Performante is so badly damaged, it will, in all likelihood, be deemed a write-off.

Model 3 Vs. E63 S AMG Vs. Grand Cherokee SRT8 In An Unlikely Three-Way Battle

The Mercedes-AMG E63 S has a twin-turbo 4.0-liter V8 and shows the Tesla Model 3 a few tricks.

Porsche Might Go All-Electric For 918 Successor – And Rimac Could Play A Role

Whatever the powertrain, Porsche’s CEO wants their next hypercar to be the best in the market.

Purple Ford GT On Huge Wheels Doesn’t Really Work, Wouldn’t You Say?

This hue isn’t offered by Ford, so it’s probably a wrap, but it’s the rims, which seem too big, that don’t quite fit.

Thou Shall Not Overpass: Transporter Misjudges Height, Car On Top Gets Smashed

Following the crash, debris scattered across all Northbound lanes of I-95, near Norwalk, Connecticut.

$465k GEV Patagonia Is The Best Way To Travel The World On Four Wheels

The GEV Patagonia can use many different chassis configurations and is a small home on off-road wheels.

Watch The Mercedes-AMG GT 63 S Put Its 630 HP To Good Use

The issue with the range-topping GT 4-Door Coupe is not power, but finding a straight long enough to unleash it.

The Nissan Stelvio Zagato Looks Like It Came From Mars And Landed On Earth

This rare Nissan Stelvio Zagato has an asking price of almost $50,000.

2020 Corvette C8 Spied As NY Auto Show Debut Appears Unlikely

The 2020 Corvette was a no show in Detroit and it doesn’t appear GM has any major introductions planned for New Year.

How Does The BMW M2 Competition Perform Against Its M4 Sibling?

The BMW M2 Competition uses a de-tuned engine from the regular BMW M4.